BAC 2025 — Physics-Chemistry, exercise 5 : Rubidium-Strontium Dating (official exam paper, solved)
Statement
Apart from carbon 14, which is used to date objects no more than 50,000 years old, there are other dating methods such as potassium-argon dating, or Rubidium-Strontium dating ...
The Geochronology Laboratory of Belgium receives two granitic rocks A and B and aims to determine the age of these rocks. To do this, it uses the Rubidium-Strontium method.
Dating by the Rubidium-Strontium pair
Some granitic rocks, during their crystallization, trap an amount of rubidium $^{87}_{37}\mathrm{Rb}$, a radioactive isotope of rubidium, with radioactive constant $\lambda=1,42.10^{-11}\,\mathrm{an^{-1}}$, and another amount of strontium formed by the stable isotopes $(^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})$, and $(^{86}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})$. A nucleus $^{87}_{37}\mathrm{Rb}$ decays to give a nucleus $^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr}$.
Figure 6: graph showing $v$ as a function of $u$ for two granitic rocks. Horizontal axis: $u$, scaled from 0 to 30. Vertical axis: $v$, scaled from 0,70 to 1,00. The two straight lines have a y-intercept close to 0,73. The line for granite A is steeper and passes approximately through $(10;0,80)$, $(20;0,88)$ and $(30;0,96)$. The line for granite B is less steep and passes approximately through $(10;0,76)$, $(20;0,81)$ and $(30;0,86)$.
5.1. Write the decay equation for the nucleus $^{87}_{37}\mathrm{Rb}$. Give, with justification, the type of radioactivity. (0,5pt)
5.2 The values $N(^{87}_{37}\mathrm{Rb})$ and $N_0(^{87}_{37}\mathrm{Rb})$ respectively represent the number of rubidium nuclei present at the current instant t and that of the nuclei that were present at the initial instant $t_0=0$, the instant of rock formation.
Show that the number $N(^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})$ of strontium nuclei formed from instant $t_0$ up to instant t has the expression $N(^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})=N(^{87}_{37}\mathrm{Rb})(e^{\lambda t}-1)$. (0,5pt)
5.3. Let $N_0(^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})$ be the initial number of strontium 87 nuclei present in the sample. Give the expression $N(^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})$ of the total number of these nuclei present in the sample at the current instant t as a function of $N(^{87}_{37}\mathrm{Rb})$, $N_0(^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})$, $\lambda$ and t. (0,75pt)
5.4. By experimentally measuring the ratios $u=\dfrac{N(^{87}_{37}\mathrm{Rb})}{N(^{86}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})}$ and $v=\dfrac{N(^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})}{N(^{86}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})}$ in the minerals of two different granitic rocks (granite A, granite B), the two graphs shown in Figure 6 are obtained. The isotope $(^{86}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})$ is used as a reference because $(^{86}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})$ is stable and its mass number does not change over time.
5.4.1. Show that one can write: $v=au+b$, by setting: $a=(e^{\lambda t}-1)$ and $b=\dfrac{N_0(^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})}{N(^{86}_{38}\mathrm{Sr})}$. (0,75pt)
5.4.2. Determine the value of the coefficient a for each of the two granitic rocks. (0,5pt)
5.4.3. Deduce the approximate age of each of the two rocks. (0,5pt)
5.5. Why was carbon 14 with a half-life of 5730 years not used to date this rock? (0,5pt)
Strategy
We use the radioactive decay law for $^{87}\mathrm{Rb}$, then express the measured isotope ratios $u$ and $v$. The slope of each straight line is $a=e^{\lambda t}-1$, so the age is obtained from $t=\dfrac{\ln(1+a)}{\lambda}$.
Step-by-step solution
1. 5.1 Decay equation and type of radioactivity
The decay equation is
$$^{87}_{37}\mathrm{Rb}\longrightarrow{}^{87}_{38}\mathrm{Sr}+{}^{0}_{-1}e+\bar\nu_e.$$
It is a $\beta^-$ decay.
… and 6 more step(s) in the full solution.
🔒 Full solution reserved
Free account: one full past-paper solution per week. Pro: every step-by-step solution, verified by computation, plus timed mock exams.
🔓 Read the full solutionKey concepts
Radioactive decay lawBeta minus decayRubidium-strontium datingIsochron lineSlope of a straight lineHalf-life and dating range
Have a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise