Baccalauréat 2021 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Asie (jour 2) remplacement — exercise 2 : Exercise A: Wine cellar (official exam paper)
Statement
Keywords: first principle and Newton’s phenomenological law, sound intensity, attenuation.
Photograph: a small wine cellar is shown; caption: “Wine cellar, Wikipedia photo”.
Tasting a wine at the right temperature is essential in order to appreciate its taste and aroma: wine that is too warm is not pleasant; wine that is too cold has its aromas masked by the alcohol. To serve wines at the right temperature, wine cellars are used.
We consider a bottle of light red wine whose ideal serving temperature is 13 °C. Initially, this bottle and its contents are at a temperature close to 22 °C. The bottle is placed in the wine cellar in order to optimize its tasting.
The air inside the wine cellar acts as a thermostat. Its temperature $T_{air}$ remains constant and equal to 13 °C.
In this exercise, we seek to determine the time required for the wine temperature to reach the desired value of 13 °C (part 1). We then study the noise disturbance that a wine cellar may cause in a restaurant (part 2).
The two parts are independent.
Part 1 – Temperature evolution - Cooling time
We study the evolution of the temperature $T$ of the system {wine + bottle} placed in the thermostat.
The system {wine + bottle} is at rest. The air in the wine cellar is ventilated.
We denote by $Q$ the heat transfer between the air and the system, and by $\Phi$ the corresponding heat flux, that is, the heat transfer per unit time.
The heat transfer and the heat flux are counted as positive if the heat transfer takes place from the air to the system.
We assume that the heat flux $\Phi$ follows Newton’s phenomenological law.
Newton’s phenomenological law
When an incompressible system at temperature $T$ is placed in a flowing fluid at temperature $T_a$, a heat flux is established between the thermostat and the system, proportional to the temperature difference $(T-T_a)$.
We can then write:
$\Phi = -h \times S \times (T - T_a)$
- $S$ is the exchange surface between the system and the thermostat (in $\mathrm{m^2}$);
- $h$ is the convective heat transfer coefficient (in $\mathrm{W\cdot m^{-2}\cdot K^{-1}}$).
Given data
- Exchange surface between the bottle and the air: $S = 4,66 \times 10^{-2}\ \mathrm{m^2}$;
- Convective heat transfer coefficient: $h = 10\ \mathrm{W\cdot m^{-2}\cdot K^{-1}}$;
- Thermal capacity of the system {wine + bottle}: $C = 3,25\ \mathrm{kJ\cdot K^{-1}}$;
- $T(K) = \theta(°C) + 273$.
1. Using the first principle of thermodynamics, relate the change in internal energy $\Delta U$ of the system {wine + bottle} to the heat transfer $Q$ between the air and the system.
2. Express the heat transfer $Q$ during a very short time interval $\Delta t$ as a function of the heat flux $\Phi$ assumed constant during this interval and of $\Delta t$. Recall the SI units of the quantities appearing in this expression.
The change in internal energy of an incompressible system at rest whose temperature varies by $\Delta T$ is given by the relation $\Delta U = C \times \Delta T$ ($C$ is the thermal capacity of the system).
3. Express the heat flux $\Phi$ as a function of the thermal capacity $C$ of the incompressible system, its temperature change $\Delta T$ and the duration $\Delta t$.
4. Using Newton’s phenomenological law, and letting $\Delta t$ tend to 0, verify that the differential equation governing the evolution of the temperature $T$ is written:
$\dfrac{dT}{dt} = -\dfrac{1}{\tau}(T - T_{air})$
Deduce the expression and the unit of $\tau$.
The time evolution model of the temperature of the system {wine + bottle}, solution of the differential equation, is as follows:
$T(t) = (T_0 - T_{air})\ e^{-\frac{t}{\tau}} + T_{air}$
This time evolution of the temperature $T(t)$ is represented below.
Graph: evolution of $T$ (in K) as a function of time $t$ (in s). The horizontal axis goes from 0 to 60000 s. The vertical axis goes from 284 K to 296 K. The curve decreases exponentially, starts at about 295 K at $t=0$, passes around 288 K at about 10000 s, around 286,5 K at about 20000 s, then tends toward the horizontal asymptote close to 286 K up to 50000 s.
5. Using the results of the model, find the values of $T_0$ and $T_{air}$.
6. Estimate graphically after how much time the wine can be served at the desired temperature (to within 0,5 degree).
Part 2 – Wine cellar and sound intensity level
The average sound intensity level of a wine cellar is 42 dB at about 1,0 m with a sound frequency close to 200 Hz. A restaurateur needs two wine cellars in the same enclosed room, close to the dining area that welcomes customers. He wants to know whether customers seated just behind the partition wall, 1,0 m from the wine cellars, are likely to hear them.
Given data
- Sound intensity level $L$ in decibel:
$L = 10\log\left(\dfrac{I}{I_0}\right)$ with $I_0 = 1,0 \times 10^{-12}\ \mathrm{W\cdot m^{-2}}$.
- Hearing threshold as a function of frequency: the following graph indicates the minimum audible sound intensity levels as a function of frequency. Graph description: the horizontal axis “Frequency (Hz)” is on a logarithmic scale from 20 Hz to 20000 Hz; the vertical axis “Sound intensity level (dB)” goes from $-20$ dB to 100 dB. The hearing-threshold curve decreases from about 60 dB at 20 Hz to about 30 dB around 80 Hz, about 20 dB at 100 Hz, about 10 dB at 200 Hz, close to 0 dB around 1000 to 2000 Hz, reaches a minimum around $-5$ to $-10$ dB around 3000 to 4000 Hz, then rises to about 10 dB at 10000 Hz and sharply beyond.
- Attenuation by absorption: the attenuation by absorption for airborne noise, denoted $A$, corresponds to the difference between the sound intensity level $L_i$ of the sound incident on an obstacle and the sound intensity level $L_t$ of the transmitted sound. It varies with frequency. For the restaurant partitions, the sound attenuation characteristics are given below:
Table:
$f$ (in Hz): 100 ; 125 ; 160 ; 200 ; 250 ; 315 ; 400 ; 500 ; 630.
$A$ (in dB): 29 ; 32 ; 28 ; 25 ; 29 ; 33 ; 36 ; 38 ; 41.
7. Show that the total sound level emitted by the two wine cellars, at 1,0 m from them without the partition wall, would be 45 dB.
8. Would the sound signal emitted by the two cellars be audible to the customers placed behind the partition wall? Justify.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise