Baccalauréat 2022 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Asie — exercise 2 : Exercise A - Formula 1: straight-line braking (official exam paper)
Statement
Keywords: mechanics, Newton's laws, modeling.
The performance of Formula 1 cars is now such that some circuits must be partly redesigned to prevent drivers from taking too many risks. Indeed, during braking, the driver can undergo decelerations of more than 6 G, knowing that an acceleration of 1G corresponds to the acceleration due to gravity, i.e. $9{,}81\ \mathrm{m\cdot s^{-2}}$: this is more than what an astronaut experiences at the launch of a rocket!
The aim of this exercise is to study the level of risk taken by a Formula 1 driver during braking on a circuit.
The study is carried out during the deceleration on the straight just before turn no. 10 of the Barcelona circuit.
Fig. 1 - Barcelona circuit - The turns are indicated by numbers - Adapted from Wikipedia. Figure described: map of the Barcelona circuit with turns numbered from 1 to 16; turn 10 is located after a long straight, in the lower right part of the track.
We study the motion of the center of mass $G$ of the system {car + driver}, of mass $m$, in the Earth reference frame, considered inertial.
Use of a simple model
The system {car + driver} moves horizontally, in a straight line, at high speed. It brakes from point A to point B (see figure 2) before entering turn no. 10.
Fig. 2 - Turn no. 10. Figure described: close-up of turn 10; point A is placed before the turn on a straight path, point B at the entrance to the turn.
To simplify the study, the situation is modeled as follows:
- During braking, the system {driver + car} undergoes:
- its weight $\vec P$;
- the resultant of the forces exerted by the road on the tires, which can be decomposed into two forces: a vertical upward force $\vec R_N$ (see figure 3) which, in the case of this motion, balances the weight $\vec P$; a horizontal force $\vec f$, of magnitude $f$, opposite to the direction of motion and modeling all the friction forces experienced by the car during its motion (see figure 3).
- We assume that the force $\vec f$ remains constant during braking.
- Braking begins at time $t=0$ when the center of mass is at point A. The speed then has the value $v_A = 321\ \mathrm{km\cdot h^{-1}}$.
- The study is carried out in the frame $(Oxy)$, with axis $(Ox)$ horizontal and oriented in the direction of motion (see figure 3). The motion takes place along axis $(Ox)$.
Fig. 3 - Diagram of the situation. Figure described: horizontal x-axis to the right, vertical y-axis upward; horizontal track. Point A is to the left of the car, point B to the right. The center of mass $G$ is at the center of the car. Vectors: $\vec R_N$ vertical upward applied at $G$, $\vec P$ vertical downward applied at $G$, $\vec f$ horizontal to the left. The direction of motion is to the right.
1. By applying Newton's second law, show that the coordinates of the acceleration vector of the system $\vec a$ are:
$\vec a = \begin{cases} a_x(t) = -\dfrac{f}{m} \\ a_y(t) = 0 \end{cases}$
We denote by $\Delta v = v_B - v_A$ the change in speed between points A and B and by $\Delta t$ the duration of the motion between A and B.
2. Justify that, in the context of this study, we can write $\Delta v = a_x \Delta t$.
The speed changes from $v_A = 321\ \mathrm{km\cdot h^{-1}}$ at point A to $v_B = 84\ \mathrm{km\cdot h^{-1}}$ at point B over the duration $\Delta t = 1{,}50\ \mathrm{s}$.
3. Calculate the acceleration value (in $\mathrm{m\cdot s^{-2}}$) from these data. Compare it with the value of 6 G mentioned in the introductory text. Recall: $1\ \mathrm{G} = 9{,}81\ \mathrm{m\cdot s^{-2}}$.
Figure 4 shows the tolerance limits of an individual taking into account the value of the acceleration (in G) and the duration for which it is experienced. In the danger zone, physiological disturbances affecting the cardiovascular and pulmonary systems may appear.
Fig. 4 - Individual tolerance limits to acceleration. Figure described: graph with logarithmic abscissa “duration (in s)” from $0{,}01$ to $30\ \mathrm{s}$ and ordinate “acceleration (in G)” from 0 to 40. A dashed curve separates below the “LOW RISK ZONE” and above the “DANGER ZONE”. Approximate points of the boundary: $(0{,}01\ \mathrm{s};18\ \mathrm{G})$, $(0{,}03\ \mathrm{s};35\ \mathrm{G})$, $(0{,}1\ \mathrm{s};32\ \mathrm{G})$, $(0{,}3\ \mathrm{s};28\ \mathrm{G})$, $(1\ \mathrm{s};20\ \mathrm{G})$, $(3\ \mathrm{s};16\ \mathrm{G})$, $(10\ \mathrm{s};12\ \mathrm{G})$, $(30\ \mathrm{s};9\ \mathrm{G})$.
4. State whether the driver is taking a health risk during braking.
Validity of the simplified model
To test the validity of the previous model, we compare the evolution of speed as a function of time predicted by the model with that deduced from measurements made using onboard sensors.
5. Show that, within the simplified model used, the $x$-coordinate $v_x(t)$ of the velocity vector has the following expression as a function of time during braking:
$v_x(t) = -\dfrac{f}{m}t + v_A \quad \text{avec } v_A = 89\ \mathrm{m\cdot s^{-1}}$
The measurements taken during the entire braking phase for turn 10 make it possible to obtain the $x$-coordinate $v_x$ of the velocity vector in real time and to plot the graph shown in figure 5.
Fig. 5 - Measurement of the $x$-coordinate of the speed during braking. Figure described: graph with vertical axis $v_x$ in $\mathrm{m\cdot s^{-1}}$ from 0 to 90, horizontal axis “Time (s)” from 0 to 1,5. Decreasing black points not perfectly aligned on a straight line, approximately: $(0;89)$, $(0{,}1;81)$, $(0{,}2;74)$, $(0{,}3;68)$, $(0{,}4;62)$, $(0{,}5;57)$, $(0{,}6;52)$, $(0{,}7;48)$, $(0{,}8;44)$, $(0{,}9;40)$, $(1{,}0;37)$, $(1{,}1;34)$, $(1{,}2;31)$, $(1{,}3;28)$, $(1{,}4;26)$, $(1{,}5;24)$.
6. Compare the shape of the graph in figure 5 with the shape predicted by the model in the previous question.
7. State which assumption of the previous model must be questioned if the entire braking phase is considered.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise