Baccalauréat 2022 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Centres étrangers - Groupe 1 (jour 1) — exercise 1 : Astronomical Telescope and Observation of Mars (official exam paper)
Statement
An amateur astronomer has just acquired an astronomical telescope with the intention of observing the North polar cap of the planet Mars.
This telescope is equipped with an objective lens of focal length 910 mm and an eyepiece of focal length 20 mm.
The objectives of this exercise are:
- Determine the maximum Earth-Mars distance needed to observe this polar cap through the telescope (Part A);
- Estimate the time needed for the telescope to reach thermal equilibrium in order to optimize observing conditions (Part B).
The two parts may be treated independently.
Photograph: image of Mars dated 30/10/2020; an arrow indicates the “Polar cap” near the upper edge of the planet. Source indicated: https://blogs.futura-sciences.com/
Part A - Maximum Earth-Mars distance allowing observation of the North polar cap
The telescope studied is an afocal telescope. It is modeled on an optical bench by two converging thin lenses L1 and L2 (see figure in APPENDIX page 15/15 to be handed in with the paper) placed so that the image focal point F’1 of lens L1 coincides with the object focal point F2 of lens L2.
We seek to form the image through the telescope of an object $A_{\infty}B_{\infty}$ located “at infinity”. Point $A_{\infty}$ is on the optical axis, point $B_{\infty}$ is off the optical axis.
- Rays coming from $A_{\infty}$ arrive at the telescope parallel to the optical axis.
- Rays coming from $B_{\infty}$ arrive at the telescope parallel to one another, with an inclination $\alpha$ relative to the optical axis.
The angle $\alpha$ is the angle under which the object $A_{\infty}B_{\infty}$ is seen with the naked eye. The angle $\alpha’$ is therefore the angle between the rays coming from $A_{\infty}$ and the rays coming from $B_{\infty}$. We denote by $\alpha’$ the angle under which the image $A’ব’$ of the object $A_{\infty}B_{\infty}$ is seen through the telescope.
Given data:
- Resolving power of the human eye: in order to distinguish two points A and B, the angle $\theta$ under which a human eye observes them must be greater than the angle $\theta_0 = 2,7 \times 10^{-4}$ rad. Associated diagram: two points A and B on the left are seen by an eye on the right; the two rays coming from A and B form angle $\theta$ at the eye.
- For a small angle $\theta$, $\tan \theta \simeq \theta$, where the angle $\theta$ is expressed in radians.
- A telescope is said to be “afocal” if it forms an image at infinity of an object located at infinity.
- The astronomical unit (AU) is a distance unit corresponding to the mean Sun-Earth distance. $1\ \mathrm{UA}=150$ million km, i.e. $1,50 \times 10^{11}$ m.
- Mean Sun-Mars distance: 1,5 UA.
The modeled telescope
1. Complete boxes 1 and 2 on the diagram, in APPENDIX page 15/15 to be handed in with the paper, by indicating the specific names given to lenses L1 and L2.
2. On the diagram, in APPENDIX page 15/15 to be handed in with the paper, draw the emergent beam coming from point $A_{\infty}$ bounded by rays 1 and 2 and passing through the telescope.
3. On the diagram, in APPENDIX page 15/15 to be handed in with the paper, similarly draw the emergent beam coming from point $B_{\infty}$ bounded by rays 3 and 4 and passing through the telescope.
4. On the diagram, in APPENDIX page 15/15 to be handed in with the paper, show the angle $\alpha’$ under which the image of the object at infinity is seen through the telescope as well as the intermediate image $A_1B_1$ (that is, the image of $A_{\infty}B_{\infty}$ through lens L1).
5. Justify the term “afocal” used to characterize this telescope.
Visibility of the polar cap
6. Recall the definition of the magnification $G$ of the telescope involving $\alpha$ and $\alpha’$.
7. Show that the magnification of the afocal telescope can be written in the form:
$G=\dfrac{f’_1}{f’_2}$
where $f’_1$ is the focal length of lens L1 and $f’_2$ is the focal length of lens L2. The small-angle approximation will be used for angles $\alpha$ and $\alpha’$.
We denote by $\alpha_{\min}$ the minimum value that angle $\alpha$ must have for the object to be observable by a human eye using this telescope.
8. Determine the expression of $\alpha_{\min}$ as a function of $f’_1$, $f’_2$ and $\theta_0$. Verify that, for the amateur astronomer’s telescope, $\alpha_{\min}=5,9 \times 10^{-6}$ rad.
9. Knowing that the size d of the North polar cap of Mars has a diameter $d$ of about $10^3$ km, give an estimate, in km, of the maximum distance $D$ between Mars and Earth allowing this polar cap to be observed.
Associated diagram: a vertical segment of length $d$ on the left is seen by an observer on the right at distance $D$; the angle at the observer is $\alpha$.
The Earth-Mars distance is not constant. It varies over time between 0,5 and 2,5 astronomical units (AU).
10. In view of the value of $D$ found in question 9, state whether the amateur astronomer will ultimately be able to observe the North polar cap of Mars with his telescope.
Part B - Thermal conditioning before observation
During an astronomical observation, one of the problems faced by astronomers is air turbulence. It appears when the air is no longer a homogeneous medium. Light then no longer propagates strictly in a straight line, and the image of what is observed is distorted. Turbulence may have several origins. One of them is instrumental turbulence, which occurs when the optical instrument used and the surrounding air are not at the same temperature. It is therefore advisable to bring the instrument “to temperature”, that is, to take it out sufficiently in advance to the observing site so that its temperature differs by less than 1°C from the outdoor air temperature.
The astronomer wants to know whether a two-hour period for bringing his instrument to temperature is sufficient to limit instrumental turbulence.
To do this, at time $t=0$, he places the telescope in contact with the outside air and measures its temperature for 20 minutes at regular time intervals. The results are shown on the graph opposite.
Experimental graph: temperature $\theta$ in °C as a function of time in min, from 0 to 120 min on the horizontal axis and from 0 to about 20 °C on the vertical axis. The experimental points are plotted only from 0 to about 20 min: the temperature starts at about 19,5 °C at $t=0$, decreases regularly, is about 17,5 °C at about 5 min, about 16 °C at about 10 min, about 14,8 °C at about 15 min and about 13,5 °C at about 20 min.
He then uses a theoretical model to predict the temperature evolution over longer durations.
Box — Newton’s law:
The thermal flux $\Phi$ between a system at temperature $\theta$ and a thermostat at temperature $\theta_e$ is proportional to the temperature difference $(\theta_e-\theta)$.
$\Phi=hS(\theta_e-\theta)$
with:
$\Phi$ : thermal flux (W);
$h$ : heat transfer coefficient (W·m$^{-2}$·°C$^{-1}$);
$S$ : area of the exchange surface between the body and the thermostat (m$^2$);
$\theta$ : body temperature (°C);
$\theta_e$ : thermostat temperature (°C).
This law correctly models exchanges dominated mainly by convection.
Given data:
- Initial temperature of the telescope: $\theta_0 = 19,5$ °C at date $t=0$.
- Outside temperature, assumed constant: $\theta_e = 9,0$ °C.
- When a stationary incompressible system undergoes a temperature change $\Delta \theta$, its internal energy change is given by the relation $\Delta U=C\Delta \theta$ ($C$ being its heat capacity).
- Mathematical reminder: $\lim_{x\to +\infty} e^{-x}=0$.
Theoretical modeling
The system studied is the astronomical telescope. It is in contact with the outside air, which plays the role of thermostat.
It is assumed that at each instant of time $t$ the different parts of the telescope are at the same temperature $\theta(t)$.
The model used is based on Newton’s law (see box above).
11. Indicate the direction of the thermal transfer that takes place during the cooling of the telescope.
12. State the first law of thermodynamics.
13. Show that the temperature change $\Delta \theta$ of the telescope over a short time $\Delta t$ satisfies the relation:
$C\Delta \theta=hS(\theta_e-\theta)\Delta t \quad (1)$
$C$ being the heat capacity of the telescope.
14. Deduce that the temperature $\theta(t)$ of the telescope satisfies the differential equation:
$\dfrac{d\theta(t)}{dt}+\dfrac{\theta(t)}{\tau}=\dfrac{\theta_e}{\tau} \quad (2)$
where $\tau$ is the characteristic cooling time, whose expression should be specified.
The solution of differential equation (2) is of the form:
$\theta(t)=A e^{-\frac{t}{\tau}}+B$ with A and B two constants.
15. Indicate the temperature value that the telescope should have at the end of the cooling. Deduce the value of constant B.
16. Determine the value of constant A, as a function of $\theta_0$ and $\theta_e$, by reasoning on the initial temperature of the telescope.
Simulation
The solution of the differential equation has been used to produce a plot based on the experimental points, leaving $\tau$ as a free parameter.
The values of A and B were set respectively to 10,5 °C and 9,0 °C.
The result is optimized for a value of $\tau=1414$ s (see graph opposite).
On the graph opposite, the experimental points are shown by “+” signs and the optimized theoretical model is shown by the solid curve.
Simulation graph: temperature $\theta$ in °C as a function of time in min, from 0 to 120 min; experimental “+” points decreasing from 19,5 °C to about 13,5 °C between 0 and 20 min; solid modeling curve decreasing, passing near the points and extended to about 40 min where it is close to 11 °C. Box on the graph: “Optimization result: $\theta(t)=A\times e^{-\frac{t}{\tau}}+B$ ; With $\tau=1414$ s”.
17. Discuss qualitatively the agreement of the theoretical model with the experimental results.
18. Using the optimization result, verify that the telescope can be considered “at temperature” at time $t=2,0$ h.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise