Baccalauréat 2022 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Nouvelle-Calédonie remplacement — exercise 1 : Ingenuity, the first helicopter to fly on Mars (official exam paper)
Statement
Ingenuity is a small helicopter - comparable to a drone - weighing a little less than two kilograms, developed by the American space agency NASA. It was tested on the surface of the planet Mars during the Mars 2020 mission to assess its capabilities in the field of optical reconnaissance of the Martian surface.
The technological challenges are considerable:
- the atmosphere of Mars is very thin, which limits the lift* generated by the rotors;
- the communication delays between Earth and Mars prevent controlling the helicopter in real time from Earth, and require a remotely programmable automatic piloting system.
Ingenuity’s first flight was successfully carried out on Monday 19 April 2021. During this 39-second test, the helicopter rose 3 meters, then hovered before landing. About ten more flights of increasing complexity followed.
* In order to fly, the rotating blades of the helicopter generate an upward vertical force called “lift”.
Figure 1: Technical specifications of Ingenuity. The image shows the Ingenuity helicopter on the Martian surface. Label: “Ingenuity, Mars exploration helicopter”. Technical specifications: range: 600 meters; mass: 1.8 kg, including 273 g of batteries; dimensions: fuselage 13.6 × 19.5 cm, rotor diameter 1.21 m; propulsion: rotors; energy source: solar cells; batteries: lithium-ion batteries; other characteristic: flight ceiling 5 meters, flight duration 90 seconds. Source: adapted from fr.m.wikipedia.org/wiki, file Mars_helicopter_on_sol_46.png.
Data:
- Technical specifications of the Ingenuity helicopter (Figure 1 above);
- Atmospheric pressure of air on Earth: $P = 1{,}013 \times 10^5\ \mathrm{Pa}$;
- Mean molar mass of air on Earth: $M = 29{,}0 \times 10^{-3}\ \mathrm{kg\cdot mol^{-1}}$;
- Ideal gas constant: $R = 8{,}314\ \mathrm{J\cdot K^{-1}\cdot mol^{-1}}$;
- Temperature conversion: $T(\mathrm{K}) = T(^\circ\mathrm{C}) + 273{,}15$;
- Gravitational field strength on Mars: $g_M = 3{,}7\ \mathrm{m\cdot s^{-2}}$;
- Gravitational field strength on Earth: $g_T = 9{,}8\ \mathrm{m\cdot s^{-2}}$;
- For an ideal gas, the relation is: $PV = nRT$, with $P$ in pascals (Pa), $V$ in $\mathrm{m^3}$, $n$ in mol, $R$ as given above, and $T$ in kelvin (K).
This exercise has 4 independent parts.
PART A: The atmosphere of Mars
Ingenuity is severely hindered in the very thin Martian atmosphere. Indeed, the density of the atmosphere is 100 times lower on Mars than on Earth.
A.1. Assuming that air is an ideal gas, show that the mass density of air (in $\mathrm{kg\cdot m^{-3}}$) on Earth $\rho_{Terre}$ satisfies the relation:
$$\rho_{Terre}=\frac{PM}{RT}$$
A.2. Calculate its value for an air temperature of 15 °C.
The mass density of the atmosphere on Mars is equal to 1% of that of the air on Earth.
A.3. Deduce the value of the mass density of the atmosphere on Mars $\rho_{Mars}$ at a temperature of 15 °C.
A.4. Knowing that lift is proportional to the mass density of the atmosphere in which the vehicle is located, explain why making a helicopter fly on Mars is a “technological challenge”.
PART B: The takeoff phase
In order to take off, the lift must at least balance the weight of the helicopter.
The following figures, on Earth (Figure 2) and on Mars (Figure 3), show the variation of the lift of the Ingenuity helicopter as a function of the rotor speed $N$ in revolutions per minute (rpm).
Figure 2: Lift on Earth as a function of rotor speed. Graph: horizontal axis “Rotational speed $N$ (rpm)” from 0 to 1000 rpm; vertical axis “Lift (N)” from 0 to 120 N. Increasing convex curve starting from 0 N at 0 rpm; approximate values read: 100 rpm → 1 N, 200 rpm → 5 N, 300 rpm → 10 N, 400 rpm → 19 N, 500 rpm → 29 N, 600 rpm → 41 N, 700 rpm → 56 N, 800 rpm → 73 N, 900 rpm → 93 N, 1000 rpm → 114 N.
Figure 3: Lift on Mars as a function of rotor speed. Graph: horizontal axis “Rotational speed $N$ (rpm)” from 0 to 3000 rpm; vertical axis “Lift (N)” from 0 to 11 N. Increasing convex curve starting from 0 N at 0 rpm; approximate values read: 500 rpm → 0.3 N, 1000 rpm → 1.1 N, 1500 rpm → 2.5 N, 2000 rpm → 4.5 N, 2500 rpm → 7.1 N, 3000 rpm → 10.3 N.
B.1. Determine the minimum rotor speed of Ingenuity on Earth and on Mars for the helicopter to take off. Comment on the result.
The candidate is invited to take initiative and present the approach followed even if it did not lead to a result. The approach is assessed and must be presented properly.
PART C: A delicate landing phase
The most delicate phase of the helicopter’s flight is landing, because of the turbulence that can destabilize the vehicle. The chosen solution is to stop the propulsion one meter above the ground, and let the helicopter reach the ground in free fall.
In the study that follows, assume that the Ingenuity helicopter is hovering - that is, at zero speed - at an altitude $H = 1{,}0\ \mathrm{m}$ above the Martian ground when its blades stop turning. It then falls vertically.
Let $Oz$ be a vertical axis, positively oriented upward and whose origin $O$ coincides with the ground (Figure 4 opposite).
Let $\vec g_M$ be the gravitational field on Mars.
Figure 4: Landing of Ingenuity. Diagram of a vertical $z$ axis (in m) oriented upward, origin $0$ at the ground. The helicopter is shown at altitude $H = 1{,}0\ \mathrm{m}$. The vector $\vec g_M$ is vertical downward.
C.1. Apply Newton’s second law to express the coordinate $a_z(t)$ of the helicopter’s acceleration vector during the free-fall phase.
C.2. Deduce, in the frame defined, the coordinate $v_z(t)$ of the helicopter’s velocity vector during the free-fall phase.
C.3. Using the previous results, deduce the time equation $z(t)$ of the helicopter’s motion during the free-fall phase.
C.4. Determine the time $t_{sol}$ after which the helicopter reaches the Martian ground.
C.5. Determine the speed $v_{sol}$ of the helicopter at the moment of impact on the Martian ground.
During preparatory tests carried out on Earth, impact speeds of the order of $16\ \mathrm{km\cdot h^{-1}}$ were recorded. Ingenuity’s landing gear was designed to withstand such speeds.
C.6. State, with justification, whether the landing gear is strong enough for use on the planet Mars.
PART D: Measuring altitude during a flight
The sensors carried by Ingenuity include a black-and-white navigation camera, a high-resolution color camera, an inertial measurement unit, an inclinometer, and an altimeter. This last sensor allows Ingenuity to know its altitude above the ground in real time.
A group of high-school students wants to build an altimeter for a drone using a capacitor whose capacitance $C$ varies as a function of the altitude $z$ at which the drone is located.
To study the characteristics of the chosen capacitor, it is placed in the circuit shown in Figure 5:
- the switch is first in position 1: the capacitor charges under the voltage $E$;
- when charging is complete, the switch is moved to position 2: the capacitor of capacitance $C$ then discharges through the resistor $R = 1{,}0\ \mathrm{k\Omega}$.
We first consider the case where the drone, and therefore the capacitor, is at ground level.
The graph in Figure 6 shows the variation of the voltage $u_C$ across the capacitor during discharge as a function of time.
Figure 5: Electrical circuit diagram. Voltage source $E$ on the left; two-position switch 1 and 2; in position 1, the capacitor is connected to the source for charging; in position 2, the capacitor $C$ is connected to a resistor $R$ for discharging. The current $i$ is indicated in the upper branch to the right. The voltage $u_R$ across $R$ is oriented to the left. The voltage $u_C$ across the capacitor is oriented upward.
Figure 6: Discharge of the capacitor at ground level. Graph: horizontal axis “time $t$ (s)” from 0 to 0.6 s; vertical axis “voltage $u_C$ (V)” from 0 to 6 V. Decreasing exponential curve starting from $u_C = 6\ \mathrm{V}$ at $t=0$ and tending to 0; approximate values read: $t=0{,}1\ \mathrm{s}$ → $u_C \approx 2{,}2\ \mathrm{V}$, $t=0{,}2\ \mathrm{s}$ → $u_C \approx 0{,}8\ \mathrm{V}$, $t=0{,}3\ \mathrm{s}$ → $u_C \approx 0{,}3\ \mathrm{V}$, $t=0{,}4\ \mathrm{s}$ → $u_C \approx 0{,}1\ \mathrm{V}$, $t=0{,}5\ \mathrm{s}$ → close to 0 V.
D.1. Show that the differential equation governing the voltage across the capacitor during its discharge (switch in position 2) can be written as:
$$\frac{du_C}{dt}+\frac{u_C}{RC}=0$$
D.2. Show that the solution of this differential equation can be written $u_C(t)=E\times e^{-\frac{t}{\tau}}$ where $\tau$ is the characteristic time of this discharge, to be expressed in terms of $R$ and $C$.
D.3. Using the graph in Figure 6, determine, and justify the answer:
D.3.1. the value of the voltage $E$;
D.3.2. the value of the characteristic time $\tau$.
D.4. Deduce that the capacitance of the capacitor at ground level is approximately $C_0 = 100\ \mathrm{\mu F}$.
When the drone rises, atmospheric pressure decreases and causes an increase in the spacing $e$ between the plates as illustrated in Figures 7 and 8 below.
Figure 7: Capacitor at ground level. Diagram of a capacitor with a flexible upper plate and a rigid lower plate. The pressures indicated inside and outside are denoted $P_{atm\ sol}$ and are equal. The distance between the plates is denoted $e$. Caption: “The pressure between the plates is the same as the outside atmospheric pressure.”
Figure 8: Capacitor at 5.0 m altitude. Similar diagram: the flexible upper plate bulges outward, the rigid lower plate remains flat; the outside pressure is denoted $P_{atm\ z=5\ m}$ and decreases, while the pressure between the plates remains $P_{atm\ sol}$. The distance between the plates increases and is denoted $e$. Caption: “The pressure between the plates remains the same as before. The outside atmospheric pressure decreases.”
Recall that the capacitance of a parallel-plate capacitor made of two plates separated by an insulator is given by:
$$C=\frac{\varepsilon S}{e}$$
with:
- $C$: capacitance of the capacitor (F)
- $\varepsilon$: dielectric permittivity of the insulator ($\mathrm{F\cdot m^{-1}}$)
- $S$: facing area of each plate ($\mathrm{m^2}$)
- $e$: distance between the two plates (m)
D.5. Explain how the capacitance $C$ of the capacitor changes when the drone moves away from the ground. Assume that the plate area remains constant.
D.6. Estimate the value of the capacitance $C$ of the capacitor at 5.0 m above the ground, knowing that the change in pressure relative to ground level causes an increase in thickness $e$ of 10%.
Recall that the capacitance $C_0$ of the capacitor at ground level is equal to 100 µF.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise