Baccalauréat 2022 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Polynésie française — exercise 1 : Oxalic salt (official exam paper)
Statement
OXALIC SALT.
Oxalic salt is a chemical substance present as a white, colorless, odorless crystalline solid. Historically, it was extracted from certain plants such as sorrel or rhubarb. In official nomenclature, it is also called ethanedioic acid, or more commonly oxalic acid. This substance is currently used in industry for the production of polymers but can also be used in many other fields: cleaning product, wasp repellent in beekeeping, etc.
The aim of this exercise is to validate two hypotheses about the type of acidity of oxalic acid and then, in a second step, to determine the formulation of this acid in a household product.
1. First hypothesis: oxalic acid is a strong diacid.
Data:
- Table giving the electronegativities of carbon, oxygen and hydrogen atoms: carbon: 2.55; oxygen: 3.44; hydrogen: 2.20.
- Semi-developed formula of oxalic acid: two carboxyl groups linked together, $\mathrm{HO{-}C(=O){-}C(=O){-}OH}$.
1.1. Give the definition of an acidic species according to Brönsted, then justify the term diacid for oxalic acid.
1.2. Draw on your paper the Lewis structure of oxalic acid as well as that of one of the two other acid-base forms. Justify the acidic character of the hydrogen atoms in the molecule.
1.3. Give the two acid/base couples associated with oxalic acid, then state the particular feature of the chemical species present in both couples.
In the laboratory, the $pH$ value of an oxalic acid solution with added-acid concentration $C_0$ equal to $5{,}00\times10^{-2}\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$ is measured. The $pH$ obtained is 1.47.
We want to model the chemical transformation between oxalic acid and water by assuming that oxalic acid behaves as a strong diacid. We will denote $\mathrm{AH_2(aq)}$ oxalic acid and $\mathrm{A^{2-}(aq)}$ the oxalate ion.
1.4. Write the equation of the reaction modeling this chemical transformation.
1.5. Deduce that, in the case of the previous hypothesis, the concentration in amount of substance of oxonium ions $[H_3O^+]$ is equal to $1{,}00\times10^{-1}\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$. You may use a reaction progress table.
Data:
- The standard concentration $c^\circ$ is equal to $1{,}0\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$.
1.6. Using the previous result, calculate the theoretical $pH$ of the solution, then justify that the hypothesis that oxalic acid is a strong diacid is not valid.
2. Second hypothesis: oxalic acid behaves as a weak monoprotic acid in solution.
Data:
- The added-acid concentration $C_0$ of the oxalic acid solution is equal to $5{,}00\times10^{-2}\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$.
- $pK_a$ value of the first acidity: $pK_{a1}=1{,}2$.
- Equation of the reaction associated with the first acidity: $\mathrm{AH_2(aq)+H_2O(\ell) \rightleftharpoons AH^-(aq)+H_3O^+(aq)}$.
- Reminder of the experimental $pH$ value of the oxalic acid solution: $pH_{exp}=1{,}47$.
2.1. Write the equation of the reaction modeling the chemical transformation of species $\mathrm{AH^-}$ with water associated with the second acidity.
2.2. Using figure 1, determine the value of the $pK_a$ of the second acidity of oxalic acid.
Figure 1: theoretical distribution diagram of the different acid-base species of oxalic acid. Horizontal axis: $pH$ from 0 to 12. Vertical axis: percentages from 0 to 100 %. Three curves: $\mathrm{AH_2}$ in dashes decreases from about 95 % at $pH=0$ to 0 % beyond $pH\approx3$; $\mathrm{AH^-}$ in dotted lines increases from about 5 % at $pH=0$, is 50 % around $pH\approx1{,}2$, reaches a maximum close to 95 % around $pH\approx2{,}8$, then decreases and is 50 % around $pH\approx4{,}3$; $\mathrm{A^{2-}}$ in solid line is almost zero before $pH\approx3$, is 50 % around $pH\approx4{,}3$, then tends toward 100 % beyond $pH\approx6$.
2.3. Using figure 1 and the real $pH$ value of the solution, give the approximate percentage of each species present in the solution, then justify that one can hypothesize that oxalic acid behaves as a monoprotic acid.
Within the framework of this second hypothesis, we will try to find the theoretical $pH$ value of the solution.
2.4. From the reaction equation given in the data, express the acidity constant $K_{a1}$ in terms of the concentrations of the different chemical species at equilibrium.
2.5. Using the previous question, justify that the oxonium ion concentration, denoted $h$, satisfies the following quadratic equation: $h^2+K_{a1}\cdot h-K_{a1}\cdot C_0=0$ with $h=[H_3O^+]_{eq}$.
To find the oxonium ion concentration, we use an incomplete python code given in figure 2 allowing direct calculation of the concentration $h$ in oxonium ions, as well as the theoretical $pH$ value of the solution.
Figure 2: python code allowing the calculation of the concentration $h$ in oxonium ions and the theoretical $pH$ value of the solution. The table contains:
1 import math
2 pKa1=float(input("pKa1 du couple :"))
3 concentration=float(input("Concentration apportée en mol/L : "))
4 Ka1=
5 ### Coefficients du polynome du deuxieme degre
6 a = 1
7 b = Ka1
8 c = -Ka1*concentration
9 ### Calcul du discriminant
10 Delta=b**2-4*a*c
11 ### Solution pour [H3O+]
12 h=(-b +sqrt(Delta))/(2*a)
13 ### pH final
14 pH = -math.log10(h)
15 ### Ecriture des résultats
16 print ('h=',format(h,"3.2E"),"mol/L", ' ',"pH final :",round(pH,2))
Result of the code: h= 3.29E-02 mol/L ; final $pH$ : 1.48.
2.6. Complete line 4 of the python code with the formula that allows the program to calculate the value of the acidity constant $K_{a1}$.
2.7. Using the result calculated by python and the data, justify the fact that oxalic acid indeed behaves as a weak monoprotic acid.
3. Formulation of oxalic acid.
When buying oxalic acid, it can be found in two different forms. In one case, it can be pure and in the other, it can be found in the dihydrate form. A laboratory technician finds a container holding a white solid labeled “oxalic acid” with no further details. Not knowing whether the product is hydrated or not, the technician decides to perform a pH-metric titration of an aqueous solution of this solid. To do so, a solution of known concentration is prepared by dissolving a mass of oxalic acid $m=0{,}27\ \mathrm{g}$ with standard uncertainty $u(m)=0{,}01\ \mathrm{g}$ in a volumetric flask of volume $V=100{,}0\ \mathrm{mL}$ with standard uncertainty $u(V)=0{,}1\ \mathrm{mL}$.
Data:
- The uncertainty $u(X)$ on a quantity $X$ when it is obtained from other independent quantities is written, for the division operation: if $X=\frac{Y}{Z}$ then $u(X)=X\cdot\sqrt{\left(\frac{u(Y)}{Y}\right)^2+\left(\frac{u(Z)}{Z}\right)^2}$. $u(X)$ is also called the combined standard uncertainty for the division operation. The other standard uncertainties often come from type B evaluation (single measurement).
- Table giving information on the two formulations of oxalic acid: pure oxalic acid: empirical formula $\mathrm{C_2H_2O_4}$, molar mass $90{,}0\ \mathrm{g\cdot mol^{-1}}$, exclamation mark safety pictogram, warning “acute toxicity”, use “in industry”; dihydrate oxalic acid: empirical formula $\mathrm{C_2H_2O_4,2H_2O}$, molar mass $126\ \mathrm{g\cdot mol^{-1}}$, exclamation mark safety pictogram, warning “toxicity”, use “household product”.
3.1. Calculate the mass concentration $C_m$ of the prepared solution together with its standard uncertainty $u(C_m)$.
The titration reaction is: $\mathrm{C_2H_2O_4 + 2\ HO^- \rightarrow C_2O_4^{2-} + 2\ H_2O}$.
3.2. Justify the coefficient 2 in front of the hydroxide ion in the reaction equation.
3.3. Give an essential characteristic of the chemical transformation so that it can be used in a direct titration.
3.4. After defining equivalence, give the relation between the amounts of substance of the titrated species $n_{titrée}$ and the titrant species $n_{titrante}$ at equivalence.
The laboratory technician takes a volume $V$ equal to $20{,}0\ \mathrm{mL}$ of the solution prepared previously. It is titrated with a sodium hydroxide solution of amount-of-substance concentration $[HO^-]=0{,}10\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$. The pH-metric titration curve is shown in figure 3.
Figure 3: graphical representation of $pH$ and $\frac{dpH}{dV_b}$ as a function of the volume of sodium hydroxide solution during the titration of oxalic acid by hydroxide ions. Horizontal axis: volume $V_b$ in mL from 0 to 16. Left vertical axis: $pH$ about 1 to 12.5. Right vertical axis: $\frac{dpH}{dV_b}$ from 0 to 20. The black curve $pH=f(V_b)$ starts at about $pH\approx1{,}7$ at $V_b=0$, increases slowly up to $pH\approx4{,}8$ around $V_b\approx8{,}2\ \mathrm{mL}$, shows a jump near $V_b\approx8{,}6\ \mathrm{mL}$, then reaches a plateau around $pH\approx12{,}2$. The blue derivative curve shows a very narrow maximum peak around $V_b\approx8{,}6\ \mathrm{mL}$, indicating the equivalence volume; the $pH$ value at equivalence is close to 7.
Data:
- Table listing colored indicators and their transition ranges: bromothymol blue: acid color yellow, basic color blue, transition range 6.0–7.6; cresol red: acid color yellow, basic color red, transition range 7.2–8.8; phenolphthalein: acid color colorless, basic color pink, transition range 8.2–10; methyl orange: acid color red, basic color yellow, transition range 3.1–4.4.
3.5. Propose the name of a suitable colored indicator, as well as the color change obtained at equivalence if the laboratory technician had chosen a colorimetric titration.
For the next question, the candidate is invited to take initiatives and present the approach followed, even if it did not succeed. The approach followed is assessed and must be presented clearly.
3.6. Using figure 3, determine the amount-of-substance concentration of oxalic acid, then justify whether the initial solid is dihydrate or not.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise