Baccalauréat 2023 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Centres étrangers - Groupe 1 — exercise 1 : Quality control of a baby bottle (official exam paper)
Statement
In infants, nitrate ions ($\mathrm{NO_3^-}$) are implicated in the occurrence of methemoglobinemia (or blue baby syndrome). The formation of nitrite ions from ingested nitrate ions is carried out by the intestinal bacterial flora. In children, excess nitrite ions cause a reduced ability of red blood cells to bind and transport oxygen.
That is why the concentration of nitrate ions in drinking water is regulated, especially for preparing baby bottles [...].
Source: Regional Health Observatory of Rhône-Alpes, 2007.
Photo: a box of powdered milk with a measuring spoon and a graduated baby bottle filled with milk.
The World Health Organization (WHO) has set the maximum concentration of nitrate ions in water at $50\ \mathrm{mg\cdot L^{-1}}$.
Moreover, independently of the amount of nitrate ions, the preservation state of milk can be assessed by measuring its acidity.
In this exercise, the aim is to:
- verify by two different methods whether tap water assumed to be drinkable meets or does not meet the WHO recommendation concerning nitrates (part A and part B);
- determine how long a prepared baby bottle can be stored before consumption (part C).
Part A - Spectrophotometric determination of nitrate ions in water
By adding 2,4-phenyldisulfonic acid, an initially colorless aqueous solution becomes yellow, more or less intense depending on its concentration in nitrate ions $\mathrm{NO_3^-}$. The concentration in $\mathrm{NO_3^-}$ ions in this solution can then be determined by measuring its absorbance at a given wavelength.
Data
• Absorption of visible light.
Table: absorption wavelengths (nm) and colors. 400-424: absorbed color violet, complementary color yellow-green. 424-491: blue, complementary color yellow. 491-575: green, complementary color magenta. 575-585: yellow, complementary color blue. 585-647: orange, complementary color blue-cyan. 647-850: red, complementary color cyan.
• Assay procedure
STEP 1: obtaining a calibration curve
To verify the mass concentration of nitrate ions $\mathrm{NO_3^-}$ in water, several dilutions of an aqueous solution S of potassium nitrate with mass concentration $t_{\mathrm{NO_3^-}}=1,0\times10^{-1}\ \mathrm{g\cdot L^{-1}}$ (with addition of 2,4-phenyldisulfonic acid) are first prepared. A color scale is then obtained from five daughter solutions S1, S2, S3, S4 and S5 with more or less nitrate ion concentration.
The absorbance $A$ of the different daughter solutions is then measured at a suitably chosen wavelength $\lambda$, and the graph of absorbance $A$ as a function of mass concentration in nitrate ions $t_{\mathrm{NO_3^-}}$ is plotted (figure 1 below).
Figure 1, calibration curve for nitrate ions $\mathrm{NO_3^-}$: graph with abscissa $t_{\mathrm{NO_3^-}}$ in $\mathrm{g\cdot L^{-1}}$ from 0 to 0,12, and ordinate absorbance $A$ from 0 to 1,8. The experimental points are approximately: S1 $(0,010 ; 0,15)$, S2 $(0,020 ; 0,30)$, S3 $(0,050 ; 0,76)$, S4 $(0,075 ; 1,10)$, S5 $(0,100 ; 1,60)$. An increasing dashed calibration line passes near the points.
STEP 2: measurement on the sample to be analyzed
A volume $V=250\ \mathrm{mL}$ of the water under study is taken and made to react with an excess of 2,4-phenyldisulfonic acid. The absorbance of this solution is then measured with the same settings as those used in STEP 1. The measured absorbance is: $A=0,48$.
The spectrophotometer used in this assay can operate with monochromatic radiation of wavelengths: 440 nm, 510 nm, 580 nm, 640 nm.
1. Indicate the most suitable wavelength for carrying out this assay. Justify your answer.
2. Use figure 1 to determine the mass concentration in nitrate ions $t_1$ of the analyzed water.
Let $u(t_1)$ be the standard uncertainty on the value of $t_1$. For this determination, the relative standard uncertainty $\dfrac{u(t_1)}{t_1}$ is estimated to be of the order of 15 %.
3. Write, keeping only one significant figure for the standard uncertainty, the measurement result for the nitrate ion concentration $t_1$.
Part B - Conductimetric titration determination of nitrate ions in the water studied
Another method of determination consists in making nitrate ions, $\mathrm{NO_3^-}$, react in acidic medium with a known amount of $\mathrm{Fe^{2+}}$ ions. This amount, noted $n(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})_{\text{totale}}$, is largely sufficient to consume all nitrate ions: this is step 1.
The excess $\mathrm{Fe^{2+}}$ ions (which have not reacted previously) are then titrated by conductimetric titration: this is step 2.
Data
• Molar masses: $M(\mathrm{NO_3^-})=62,0\ \mathrm{g\cdot mol^{-1}}$ ; $M(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})=55,8\ \mathrm{g\cdot mol^{-1}}$ ; $M(\mathrm{Cr_2O_7^{2-}})=216\ \mathrm{g\cdot mol^{-1}}$.
• Titration procedure:
STEP 1: a volume $V=250,0\pm0,2\ \mathrm{mL}$ of the water studied in part A is taken. This volume is made to react with an acidified solution containing $n(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})_{\text{totale}}=4,0\times10^{-3}\ \mathrm{mol}$ of $\mathrm{Fe^{2+}}$ ions.
The reaction equation is:
$\mathrm{NO_3^-(aq)+3\ Fe^{2+}(aq)+4\ H_3O^+(aq)\rightarrow NO(g)+3\ Fe^{3+}(aq)+6\ H_2O(\ell)}$ (equation 1)
We denote by $n(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})_{\text{excès}}$ the amount of substance in $\mathrm{Fe^{2+}}$ ions still present at the final state of reaction equation 1.
STEP 2: the amount of substance $n(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})_{\text{excès}}$ is determined by titration with dichromate ions $\mathrm{Cr_2O_7^{2-}}$ from an aqueous potassium dichromate solution for which $[\mathrm{Cr_2O_7^{2-}}]=C=5,0\times10^{-2}\pm0,2\times10^{-2}\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$.
The reaction equation supporting this titration is:
$\mathrm{Cr_2O_7^{2-}(aq)+6\ Fe^{2+}(aq)+14\ H_3O^+(aq)\rightarrow 2\ Cr^{3+}(aq)+6\ Fe^{3+}(aq)+21\ H_2O(\ell)}$ (equation 2)
The titration curve obtained is shown in figure 2 below.
Figure 2, conductimetric titration curve of the analyzed water: graph with abscissa the volume of potassium dichromate solution added in mL from 0 to 25 and ordinate conductivity in $\mathrm{mS\cdot cm^{-1}}$ from 5 to 11. The points decrease almost linearly from about 10,2 at 0 mL to about 7,2 at 12 mL, then increase slightly to about 7,7 at 25 mL. The change in slope is around $V_E\approx12\ \mathrm{mL}$.
4. Identify the titrated reactant and the titrant reactant during the titration in STEP 2.
5. From the analysis of figure 2, show that the amount of matter of the $\mathrm{Fe^{2+}}$ ions that were added in excess $n(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})_{\text{excès}}$ is about 3,6 mmol.
The amount of nitrate ions sought, $n(\mathrm{NO_3^-})$, can be calculated from the amount of $\mathrm{Fe^{2+}}$ ions initially introduced during STEP 1, $n(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})_{\text{totale}}$, and from the amount of $\mathrm{Fe^{2+}}$ ions titrated during the titration $n(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})_{\text{excès}}$ using the following relation:
$n(\mathrm{NO_3^-})=\dfrac{1}{3}\left[n(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})_{\text{totale}}-n(\mathrm{Fe^{2+}})_{\text{excès}}\right]$
6. Justify this relation.
7. Calculate the amount of nitrate ion $n(\mathrm{NO_3^-})$ present in the water sample. Deduce that the mass concentration in nitrate ion $t_2$ is about $33\ \mathrm{mg\cdot L^{-1}}$.
The standard uncertainty $u(t_2)$ on the value of concentration $t_2$ of nitrates determined with the titration is given by:
$u(t_2)=t_2\times\sqrt{\left(\dfrac{u(C)}{C}\right)^2+\left(\dfrac{u(V_E)}{V_E}\right)^2+\left(\dfrac{u(V)}{V}\right)^2}$
with:
• $u(V_E)=0,5\ \mathrm{mL}$, standard uncertainty on the value of the volume $V_E$ of titrant solution added at equivalence.
• $u(V)$, standard uncertainty on the value of the volume of titrated solution $V$.
• $u(C)$, standard uncertainty on the value of the amount-of-substance concentration $[\mathrm{Cr_2O_7^{2-}}]=C$ in dichromate ions $\mathrm{Cr_2O_7^{2-}}$.
8. Calculate the standard uncertainty $u(t_2)$ of the nitrate content, then give a bounds estimate for the mass concentration $t_2$ obtained with this titration method.
9. Conclude on the potability of the sampled water in light of the results obtained by the two dosage methods studied.
Part C - How long can a baby bottle prepared with powdered milk be stored?
A baby bottle is prepared by dissolving powdered milk in water.
Milk has a slight acidity that can develop quite quickly depending on storage conditions. Indeed, the lactose present in milk is gradually transformed into lactic acid.
The state of preservation of milk is checked by measuring its acidity expressed in Dornic degrees (°D). One Dornic degree, written 1°D, corresponds to 0,10 g of lactic acid per liter of milk.
Data
• Semi-developed formula of lactic acid: $\mathrm{CH_3-CH(OH)-C(=O)-OH}$ (represented with a hydroxyl group on the central carbon and a carboxyl group $\mathrm{-COOH}$).
• Molar mass of lactic acid: $M=90,0\ \mathrm{g\cdot mol^{-1}}$.
• $pK_a$ (lactic acid/lactate ion) = 3,9.
• Acid/base pairs of water: $\mathrm{H_3O^+(aq)/H_2O(\ell)}$ ; $\mathrm{H_2O(\ell)/HO^-(aq)}$.
• Reminder: $pK_a=-\log K_a$.
The lactic acid / lactate ion pair
10. Copy the semi-developed formula of lactic acid, circle the characteristic groups and indicate their names.
11. Draw the Lewis structure of the lactate ion, the conjugate base of lactic acid.
For the rest, let AH denote lactic acid and A− its conjugate base. The chemical reaction between lactic acid AH and the water in the bottle leads to a chemical equilibrium:
$\mathrm{AH(aq)+H_2O(\ell)\rightleftharpoons A^-(aq)+H_3O^+(aq)}$
Laboratory measurement of the pH of the milk contained in the bottle gives pH = 6,2.
12. After drawing the predominance diagram of the AH/A− pair, indicate which species predominates in the milk in the bottle.
13. Express the acidity constant $K_a$ of the pair AH/A− in terms of the concentrations [AH], [A−], [$\mathrm{H_3O^+}$] and $c^\circ$ with $c^\circ=1\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$, the standard concentration.
14. Deduce that the lactate ion concentration [A−] in the milk in the bottle is about 200 times greater than that of lactic acid [AH].
Determination of lactic acid
In order to determine the concentration of lactic acid in the milk, the following procedure is used:
- Pour $V_L=40,0\ \mathrm{mL}$ of milk into an Erlenmeyer flask.
- Add $V_{eau}=150\ \mathrm{mL}$ of distilled water.
- Add a few drops of colored indicator (which will make it possible to detect equivalence).
- Place the Erlenmeyer flask under a burette filled with sodium hydroxide solution ($\mathrm{Na^+,HO^-}$) of concentration $c_B=2,0\times10^{-2}\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$ and stir.
- Add until the color changes and record the volume of sodium hydroxide added $V_{BE}$.
For the same milk sample, the operation is repeated several times. The values of $V_{BE}$ thus obtained are grouped in the table below: $V_{BE}$ (mL): 12,3 ; 12,2 ; 12,4 ; 12,0 ; 12,1 ; 12,2.
The average value of these values is $\overline{V_{BE}}=12,2\ \mathrm{mL}$.
During the transformation, the acid-base pairs involved are: AH/A− and $\mathrm{H_2O/HO^-}$.
15. Write the reaction supporting the titration.
16. Determine the mass concentration of lactic acid in the baby bottle milk.
The spread in the $V_{BE}$ measurements can be explained by inaccuracies in the values of certain parameters.
17. Among the following two parameters, milk volume, $V_L$, and distilled water volume, $V_{eau}$, indicate which one has an effect on the value of $V_{BE}$.
Time evolution of the lactic acid concentration in several samples
Tests were carried out on three samples taken from the milk of a standard baby bottle prepared by dissolving powdered milk in water. These samples were then stored for several days at the following temperatures:
• Sample 1: 5 °C.
• Sample 2: 20 °C.
• Sample 3: 30 °C.
A titration follow-up made it possible to determine the mass concentration of lactic acid in each sample as a function of time. The results obtained are shown below (figure 3). Each curve corresponds to one of the samples studied.
Figure 3, kinetic monitoring of lactic acid formation for three temperatures: graph with abscissa time in hours from 0 to 50 and ordinate lactic acid concentration in $\mathrm{g\cdot L^{-1}}$ from 0 to 2,5. The three curves start around $0,55\ \mathrm{g\cdot L^{-1}}$. Curve (a), gray: increases rapidly, about 0,8 at 10 h, 1,4 at 20 h, 2,2 at 28 h. Curve (b), orange: increases more slowly, about 0,6 at 15 h, 0,9 at 25 h, 1,25 at 35 h, 1,8 at 42 h, 2,3 at 47 h. Curve (c), blue: remains almost horizontal, about 0,55 at 0 h, 0,60 at 30 h, 0,70 at 47 h.
According to current standards, milk is considered fresh if its acidity is below 18°D.
18. Using the graph in figure 3, determine after how long samples 2 and 3 are no longer considered fresh milk.
The candidate is invited to take initiative and present the method followed, even if it was not successful. The method is assessed and must be presented correctly.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise