Baccalauréat 2023 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Nouvelle-Calédonie (jour 1) — exercise 2 : Observing Saturn (official exam paper)
Statement
“On 20 June 2019, Saturn came closest to Earth, at 1.36 billion kilometres. [...] The Hubble Space Telescope was able to photograph Saturn, particularly visible because it was fully illuminated by the Sun (Figure 1). Saturn and its ring system always provide an exceptional spectacle. [...] They are made up of particles of ice and rock, several tens of thousands of kilometres in size and extremely thin.”
Source: adapted from www.futura-sciences.com
Figure 1: image of Saturn from the Hubble Space Telescope © Nasa, ESA, photo taken on 20 June 2019, https://hubblesite.org. The planet Saturn is surrounded by its rings; two points are marked: $A_\infty$ at the apparent centre of the planet and $B_\infty$ on the outer ring. Satellites are named in the image: Enceladus, Janus, Mimas, Tethys.
The proposed exercise studies the eye’s ability to take advantage of the “exceptional spectacle” that can be offered by observing the planet Saturn with an astronomical telescope.
On Figure 1, two points considered to be infinitely far from Earth are identified:
- the centre of planet Saturn, denoted $A_\infty$;
- a point on the outer ring, denoted $B_\infty$.
Given:
- Distance $A_\infty B_\infty=1,1\times10^8\ \mathrm{m}$.
- The wavelength of the brightest radiation scattered by Saturn is $\lambda=705\ \mathrm{nm}$.
- The apparent angle $\alpha$ under which an object $AB$ is seen by the naked eye is represented in Figure 2. Figure 2: diagram of an eye observing a vertical segment $AB$, with angle $\alpha$ being the angle between the direction to $A$ and the direction to $B$.
- A normal eye is considered unable to distinguish two object points A and B that are very close if the apparent angle under which they are seen is less than $2,9\times10^{-4}\ \mathrm{rad}$.
- The apparent angle under which Saturn’s ring system is seen from Earth is $\alpha=8\times10^{-5}\ \mathrm{rad}$ when Saturn is closest to Earth.
- For small angles expressed in radians, one may write $\tan\alpha\approx\alpha$.
- The resolving power of an optical instrument represents its ability to separate two very close object points A and B. The angular resolution limit of an optical instrument is the smallest apparent angle $\alpha_{lim}$ under which two object points whose images are distinct through the telescope are observed. According to the Rayleigh criterion, two object points are resolved if $\alpha$ (in radians) is greater than the resolution limit $\alpha_{lim}$, i.e. $\alpha>\alpha_{lim}=1,22\times\frac{\lambda}{D}$ where $D$ is the diameter of the objective and $\lambda$ the wavelength of the radiation emitted with maximum intensity by the observed object points.
Part A - Resolution limit of an astronomical telescope and resolving power of the eye
The astronomical telescope and the eye are limited in their ability to distinguish two object points.
A.1. Determine whether or not it is possible to enjoy the “exceptional spectacle” that can be offered by observing the planet Saturn with its rings with the naked eye.
Saturn is observed with an astronomical telescope, an excerpt from whose technical notice is reproduced in Figure 3.
Figure 3: excerpt from the notice for an astronomical telescope: objective diameter 70 mm; objective focal length 900 mm; slow friction motion; alt-azimuth mount; aperture 70; eyepiece focal lengths 20 mm and 10 mm; magnification with supplied equipment 45 X and 90 X.
A.2. Using the Rayleigh criterion, determine the angular resolution limit $\alpha_{lim}$ of this commercial telescope.
A.3. Indicate whether the wave phenomenon limiting resolution prevents or does not prevent observation of Saturn with the proposed telescope.
Part B - Formation of the image of Saturn and its rings
On the diagram in APPENDIX II TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET (page 13/13), the astronomical telescope is modelled using two converging thin lenses $L_1$ and $L_2$, with optical centres $O_1$ and $O_2$ respectively and optical axis $\Delta$.
The afocal telescope is adjusted to provide the best observing conditions. It gives from an object $A_\infty B_\infty$, located at infinity, an image $A'_\infty B'_\infty$ located at infinity, observable without accommodation for a normal eye.
The planet Saturn and its rings, assumed to be at infinity, are represented without regard to scale by $A_\infty B_\infty$, with point $A_\infty$ on the optical axis. A light ray originating from $B_\infty$ is also shown.
B.1.1. Identify on the diagram in APPENDIX II TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET (page 13/13), the objective $L_1$ and the eyepiece $L_2$.
B.1.2. Place on the diagram in APPENDIX II TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET (page 13/13):
- the respective optical centres $O_1$ and $O_2$;
- the image focus $F'_1$ of $L_1$ and the object focus $F_2$ of $L_2$, not to scale but consistently.
B.2. Draw on the diagram in APPENDIX II TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET (page 13/13):
- the intermediate image $A_1B_1$ of the object $A_\infty B_\infty$ given by the objective $L_1$;
- the emergent beam of the telescope coming from $B_\infty$ and passing through the edges of the objective.
Part C - Magnification of the astronomical telescope
The magnification of the telescope is given by the expression: $G=\frac{\alpha'}{\alpha}$, $\alpha'$ being the angle under which one sees the image $A'_\infty B'_\infty$ of the object $A_\infty B_\infty$ through the instrument.
C.1. Locate $\alpha'$ on the diagram in APPENDIX II TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET (page 13/13).
C.2. Derive the expression for the magnification $G$ in terms of the focal lengths $f'_1$ of the objective and $f'_2$ of the eyepiece.
The observer uses the eyepiece with focal length 20 mm.
C.3. Validate the value of the magnification “45 X” of the commercial telescope described in Figure 3.
C.4. Determine whether the eye can theoretically distinguish Saturn’s rings with the help of this telescope.
The candidate is invited to take initiatives and to present the approach followed, even if it did not lead to a result. The approach is assessed and must be clearly presented.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise