Solved exercises🧮 Solve my exercise

Baccalauréat 2023 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Métropole, Mayotte, Antilles Guyane — exercise 1 : Discovering Saturn (official exam paper)

PhysicsLevel : High schoolDiscovering Saturn🌐 Lire en français
Statement
The planet Saturn was observed through an astronomical telescope for the first time by the astronomer Galileo in 1610. He was able to glimpse the planet, but his telescope did not allow him to clearly distinguish what surrounded it (figure 1). It was only in 1655, thanks to a more advanced telescope, that Christian Huygens understood that what surrounds Saturn are rings whose appearance varies with the viewing angle. The same year, he also discovered Titan, Saturn’s largest satellite (figures 2 and 3). Figure 1. Saturn as represented by Galileo in 1610: a very schematic drawing showing a central disk surrounded by two small side disks, with no clear separation of rings. Figure 2. One of the first drawings of Saturn made by Huygens in 1655: Saturn’s disk crossed by a flattened ring. Figure 3. Respective positions of Saturn and Titan schematized by Huygens in 1655: several point positions of Titan shown near Saturn. Source: Huygens’ Systema Saturnium. The aim of this exercise is to study Huygens’ astronomical telescope in order to compare his observations of Saturn and its rings with those of Galileo. The end of the exercise is devoted to the study of the motion of the satellite Titan from Huygens’ observations. Data: - characteristics of the astronomical telescopes used by Galileo and Huygens: table with 4 columns “Focal length $f'_1$ of the objective”, “Focal length $f'_2$ of the eyepiece”, “Diameter $a$ of the objective”, “Magnification”. Line “Galileo’s telescope used in 1610”: focal length of the objective not given, focal length of the eyepiece not given, diameter $a = 29,0\ \text{mm}$, magnification $G_{\text{Gal}} = 14$. Line “Huygens’ telescope used in 1655”: $f'_1 = 329\ \text{cm}$, $f'_2 = 7,0\ \text{cm}$, diameter $a = 51,0\ \text{mm}$, magnification not given. - an observer can distinguish two different points of an object if the angle under which these two points are seen, from the observation point, is greater than or equal to $3,0\times10^{-4}\ \text{rad}$; - approximation for small angles $(\theta \ll 1\ \text{rad})$: $\tan(\theta)=\theta$; - universal gravitational constant: $G = 6,67\times10^{-11}\ \text{N}\cdot\text{m}^2\cdot\text{kg}^{-2}$; - mass of Saturn: $M_S = 5,68\times10^{26}\ \text{kg}$; - mass of Titan: $M_T = 1,34\times10^{23}\ \text{kg}$; - average distance between Earth and Saturn: $D_{T-S} = 1,42\times10^9\ \text{km}$; - radius of Titan’s orbit around Saturn: $R = 1,22\times10^6\ \text{km}$. 1. Observation of Saturn by Huygens Huygens’ telescope, considered as afocal, is modeled by a system of two converging thin lenses denoted L1 and L2. Lens L1 represents the objective and lens L2 the eyepiece. Their respective optical centers are denoted O1 and O2 and their respective focal lengths are denoted $f'_1$ and $f'_2$. In figure A1 of the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET, drawn without regard to scale, the two lenses and the position of the image focus F’1 of lens L1 are shown. The telescope is used to observe an object AB, assumed to be “at infinity”, whose image by the objective will be denoted A1B1. Two light rays originating from B are shown in the diagram. Description of figure A1 according to the statement: diagram of a telescope with two converging lenses L1 and L2 aligned on an optical axis, with the image focus F’1 of L1 indicated; two parallel rays coming from point B of an object at infinity arrive on L1 and must form the intermediate image A1B1 before emerging through L2. Q1. State the meaning of the term “afocal”. Q2. Place, on figure A1 of the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET, the object focus F2 and image focus F’2 of lens L2 in the case of an afocal telescope. Q3. Construct, on figure A1 of the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET, the path of the two light rays originating from B that emerge from the telescope, showing the intermediate image A1B1. Huygens’ telescope consists of a tube 372 cm long. As shown in figure 4, the eyepiece is placed at one end of the tube. The objective, on the other hand, is inserted 36 cm from the other end, in order to protect it from fogging. Figure 4. Schematic representation of Huygens’ telescope (not to scale): horizontal tube of length $L = 372\ \text{cm}$; on the left, objective lens with center O1 located inside the tube, set back by $\ell = 36\ \text{cm}$ from the left end; on the right, eyepiece lens with center O2 placed at the right end; the optical axis is horizontal and passes through O1 and O2. Q4. Verify, using the data, that Huygens’ telescope can be considered “afocal”. The angle $\theta$, shown in figure A1 of the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET, denotes the angle under which the gap AB between the surface of Saturn and its first ring is seen with the naked eye from Earth, when Saturn’s rings are seen face-on (see figure 5). Figure 5. Angle under which Saturn is seen by Huygens without the telescope (not to scale): Saturn is represented with its ring seen face-on; point A is located on Saturn’s surface and point B on the first ring above A; the distance between A and B is denoted $D_{A-B}$; the Earth observer is on the right; the Earth-Saturn distance is denoted $D_{T-S}$; the angle at the observer between the directions toward A and B is $\theta$. Let $\theta’$ be the angle under which an observer sees the image A’B’ of the gap AB, through the astronomical telescope. Q5. Place the angle $\theta’$ on figure A1 of the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET. Q6. Give the expression for the magnification $G_{\text{Huy}}$ of Huygens’ telescope in terms of the angles $\theta$ and $\theta’$. Q7. Show that the magnification $G_{\text{Huy}}$ of Huygens’ telescope can be expressed in terms of the focal lengths of lenses L1 and L2 making up the telescope: $G_{\text{Huy}}=\dfrac{f'_1}{f'_2}$. Q8. Calculate the value of the magnification $G_{\text{Huy}}$ of the telescope used by Huygens. Q9. Conclude on whether Huygens could distinguish Saturn’s surface from its first ring using the telescope. The distance between Saturn’s surface and its first ring is equal to $D_{A-B} = 3,17\times10^4\ \text{km}$ (figure 5). 2. Taking diffraction into account in astronomical observation The observation of details of an object with an astronomical telescope is mainly limited by the phenomenon of diffraction. Indeed, the image given by the objective of a point source “at infinity” is not a point but a circular diffraction pattern, called the Airy disk, shown in figure 6. Figure 6. Diffraction pattern obtained by a circular aperture (not to scale – negative image): parallel rays from a distant point light source arrive on a circular aperture of diameter $a$; after the aperture, the diffracted beam diverges slightly and forms on a screen a central dark circular spot surrounded by brighter concentric rings; the angle between the central axis and the direction of the edge of the central spot is denoted $\theta_{\text{diff}}$. In the case of the astronomical telescope, it is assumed that the characteristic diffraction angle satisfies the relation: $\theta_{\text{diff}} = 1,22\times\dfrac{\lambda}{a}$, where $\lambda$ is the wavelength of the incident beam and $a$ the diameter of the objective. An astronomical telescope allows two points A and B to be distinguished only if the angular separation $\theta$ between the directions of these two points as seen from Earth is greater than or equal to the characteristic diffraction angle, that is, if the condition $\theta \geq \theta_{\text{diff}}$ is satisfied. If this is not the case, the Airy disks associated with the two points overlap and the two points cannot be visually separated. Q10. Explain why diffraction can be considered to have prevented Galileo from observing Saturn’s rings with his telescope, unlike Huygens who was able to observe them. A quantitative approach is expected. Recall that the distance between Saturn and the boundary of the first visible ring at the time is equal to $D_{A-B} = 3,17\times10^4\ \text{km}$ and use a wavelength value of $\lambda = 550\ \text{nm}$, for which the human eye is most sensitive. The candidate is invited to take initiatives and present the approach followed, even if it did not lead to a result. The approach is assessed and must be clearly presented. 3. Huygens’ discovery of Titan On 25 March 1655, at 8 p.m., using his telescope, Huygens noticed near Saturn a bright point which he suspected to be a satellite of this planet. Later, this satellite would be called Titan. “After 25 March 1655, namely on 10 April, the satellite was seen at the same position it occupied on that first date. Likewise, on 3 and 19 April of that same year identical positions were observed; likewise again on 13 and 29 of that month. Taking these results into account, I drew a circle representing the orbit of the satellite, with Saturn at the center, and I divided it into 16 parts, as shown in the following figure. In this orbit I made the satellite move in the natural order of the numbers. […] Then, looking on this circumference for the place where the satellite had been at our first observation and correcting this place several times, […] it finally seemed to me that the whole motion could most conveniently be represented if, in the case of the first observation, that of 25 March 1655, the satellite is placed near the number 12. Consequently the satellite of Saturn was on 26 March near the number 13, on 27 March near the number 14, on 3 April near the number 5 and so on at the places in the orbit which fairly match the situations observed in the first year.” Diagram from Systema Saturnium, Huygens: circular orbit drawn around Saturn, divided into 16 numbered positions; a vertical line divides the circle; the indicated positions include 25 March near number 12 on the right side, 26 March near number 13, 27 March near number 14 and 3 April near number 5. Source: from Systema Saturnium, Huygens. Q11. Justify Huygens’ choice to divide Titan’s trajectory into 16 parts. Titan’s motion, denoted T, is studied in the Saturn-centered reference frame, whose origin is located at the center S of Saturn and whose axes are directed toward distant stars. It is considered Galilean. We work in the Frenet frame $(T,\vec{u_t},\vec{u_n})$. Figure 7. Diagram of Titan’s trajectory in the Saturn-centered reference frame: circular orbit centered at S; Titan T is placed on the orbit; the radius $R$ connects S to T; the tangent vector $\vec{u_t}$ is oriented in the direction of motion; the normal vector $\vec{u_n}$ is directed from T toward S. In Systema Saturnium, Huygens states that the value of Titan’s orbital period $T_{\text{Huy}}$ is “15 days 23 hours 13 minutes”. Q12. Give the vector expression of the gravitational interaction force exerted by Saturn on the satellite Titan as a function of $G$, $M_S$, $M_T$, $R$ and one of the unit vectors. Q13. Titan’s motion around S is assumed to be circular. Show that it is uniform, then show that the satellite’s speed can be written in the form: $v=\sqrt{\dfrac{G\cdot M_S}{R}}$. Q14. Deduce the expression of the orbital period denoted $T_{\text{Kep}}$ of Titan. Calculate its value. Comment.
⏳ Solution not generated yet

Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.

📝 See the solution

Have a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.

🧮 Solve my exercise