Baccalauréat 2024 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Centres étrangers - Groupe 1 — exercise 2 : Acoustic Safety (official exam paper)
Statement
Climate change has an impact on the frequency and intensity of hail episodes. “A frequency increased by 30%, an intensity increased on average by 10% to 15%,” says Jean Jouzel, climatologist and former member of the IPCC.
In order to protect their crops from the damage that hail can cause, some farmers have chosen to install hail cannons (photograph opposite). These are short shock-wave generators, made up of an explosion chamber (1) and a conical diffuser (2).
Photograph: a hail cannon is shown; the lower part is a box or explosion chamber marked 1, and the upper part is a long vertical conical diffuser marked 2. Source: https://www.francebleu.fr
The main disadvantage of this type of installation is the noise nuisance caused by the loud explosions that follow one another when a storm is forecast.
In this exercise, we will look at the following questions: what is the order of magnitude of the sound risk linked to the use of the hail cannon for a person who lives or works nearby? Can it be prevented using a device called a “silencer”, installed on the cannon?
Data:
- Acoustic power of a hail cannon: $P=503\ \mathrm{W}$.
- For a point sound source, the sound intensity $I$ at a distance $d$ from the source is related to the sound power $P$ of this source by the relation: $I=\dfrac{P}{4\times\pi\times d^2}$.
- Reference sound intensity: $I_0=1,00\times10^{-12}\ \mathrm{W\cdot m^{-2}}$.
- Sound intensity level: $L=10\times\log\left(\dfrac{I}{I_0}\right)$.
1. Sound risk from the hail cannon
We aim to study the sound risk from the hail cannon for a person who works occasionally nearby in order to advise them on preventive actions.
Q1. Calculate the value of the sound intensity $I_1$ perceived by a worker located at a distance $d_1=1,00\ \mathrm{m}$ from the hail cannon.
Q2. Show that the sound intensity level $L_1$ at the distance $d_1=1,00\ \mathrm{m}$ from the cannon is $L_1=136\ \mathrm{dB}$.
Q3. Using document 1, page 8, state what advice should be given to a person exposed to noise who works within a one-meter perimeter around a hail cannon in operation.
Document 1 - Exposure limit values. Table: columns “Daily exposure over 8 h”, “Short noises”, “Required actions”.
- Row 1: daily exposure: “Whatever the level”; short noises: not specified; required actions: “No obligation to implement specific actions. Risk assessment. Elimination or reduction to a minimum of risks linked to noise exposure.”
- Row 2: daily exposure “Greater than or equal to 80 dB and less than 85 dB”; short noises “Greater than or equal to 135 dB and less than 137 dB”; required actions: “Provision of individual hearing protection (IHP). Information and training of workers on the risks and the IHP. Preventive audiometric examination offered.”
- Row 3: daily exposure “Greater than or equal to 85 dB and less than 87 dB”; short noises “Greater than or equal to 137 dB and less than 140 dB”; required actions: “Implementation of a program of measures to reduce noise exposure. Signposting of the areas concerned and restricted access. Mandatory wearing of the IHP. Monitoring of the effective wearing of the IHP. Regular preventive audiometric examination.”
- Row 4: daily exposure “Greater than or equal to 87 dB”; short noises “Greater than or equal to 140 dB”; required actions: “Signposting of the areas concerned, restriction and control of access. Immediate adoption of noise reduction measures.”
According to https://www.cmsm.fr/wp-content/uploads/2019/12/bruit_et_reglementation.pdf
We now aim to study the sound risk from the hail cannon for a resident of the area, continuously exposed to the noise of the cannon.
On the plan below, we denote C the position of the hail cannon and H the position of the resident in their home. We denote $d_2$ the distance between the cannon and the dwelling ($d_2=HC$).
Plan: aerial image of agricultural plots and a dwelling. Point H is on the left, near the dwelling; point C is on the right, in a plot. Scale shown on the image: “1 cm corresponds to 100 m”. A printed ruler under the image indicates a 1 cm segment; the distance HC measured on the plan is about 7 cm, i.e. about 700 m.
We will assume that $L_2=L_1-20\times\log\left(\dfrac{d_2}{d_1}\right)$.
Q4. Using the plan, determine the value of the distance $d_2$ and deduce the value of the sound intensity level $L_2$ of a detonation heard at the dwelling H.
Q5. Determine whether the detonations of the hail cannon present a sound risk for the inhabitants of the dwelling H and explain why.
Sound intensity level is not the only risk factor. We call sound emergence $\varepsilon_S$ the change in the ambient sound intensity level due to a sudden noise. Sound emergence can lead to an increase in stress.
As a first approach, sound emergence can be estimated by the difference in sound intensity level between a punctual sound and the ambient sound. The public health code states that sound emergence must not exceed +5 dB during the day and +3 dB at night.
These elements will make it possible to refine the study of the acoustic risk around the dwelling. The average ambient sound intensity level around dwelling H, $L_H$, is $L_H=65\ \mathrm{dB}$. At the moment of an explosion of the cannon, the sound intensity level of the detonation heard at the level of dwelling H, $L_2$, is measured at $L_2=75\ \mathrm{dB}$.
Q6. Calculate, at the level of the dwelling, the value of the sound emergence $\varepsilon_S$ due to the operation of the cannon.
Q7. Comment on this result in light of the requirements of the public health code.
2. Reducing a risk using a silencer
In order to solve the risks studied previously, the hail cannon is equipped with a silencer surrounding the cannon. This silencer is made up of a casing lined on the inside with a sound-insulating material.
The acoustic absorption coefficient $C_{\text{abs}}$ of a material used for sound insulation characterizes its ability to attenuate sounds. The higher the acoustic absorption coefficient, the better the insulation. It is a quantity without units.
We assume that a cannon shot is a sound of frequency $f$ of about 1000 Hz.
Q8. Among the materials presented in document 2, page 10, specify which one is the most suitable for lining the walls of the silencer. Justify.
Document 2 - Variation of the acoustic absorption coefficient $C_{\text{abs}}$ of different materials as a function of the frequency $f$ of the sound to be absorbed, for a material thickness of 30 mm. Three graphs show the absorption coefficient as a function of frequency, from 0 to 6000 Hz.
- a) Open-cell foam 30 mm: the coefficient increases regularly from about 0 at 0 Hz, 0.15 at 500 Hz, 0.28 at 1000 Hz, 0.42 at 1500 Hz, 0.58 at 2000 Hz, 0.72 at 2500 Hz, then reaches about 0.78 at 3000-3500 Hz and remains close to 0.72 to 0.76 up to 6000 Hz.
- b) Smooth-surface foam 30 mm: the coefficient is about 0 at 0 Hz, 0.4 at 300-500 Hz, about 0.45-0.50 around 1000 Hz, reaches a maximum close to 0.9 around 1300 Hz, then falls to 0.65 at 1600 Hz, 0.5 around 2200-2500 Hz, 0.3 at 3000 Hz, rises again to 0.5 around 4500-5000 Hz, then falls again to 0.32 at 6000 Hz.
- c) Melamine foam 30 mm: the coefficient increases from about 0 at 0 Hz, 0.25 at 600 Hz, 0.38 at 900 Hz, about 0.45 at 1000 Hz, 0.55 at 1300 Hz, 0.62 at 1600 Hz, 0.80 at 2000 Hz, then reaches about 0.9 between 2500 and 3500 Hz and remains close to 0.85-0.90 up to 6000 Hz.
Source: https://www.solutions-elastomeres.com/
The material chosen in question Q8 makes it possible, on average, to reduce by 14 dB the transmission of noise through the walls of the hail cannon.
Q9. Determine whether the hail cannon fitted with a silencer represents a sound risk factor at the level of dwelling H according to the requirements of the public health code. Justify.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise