Baccalauréat 2024 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Asie (jour 1) — exercise 1 : Never mix bleach and acid (official exam paper)
Statement
In an article dated 25 April 2023, the French national agency for food, environmental and occupational health and safety (ANSES) warns about the increase in accidents involving private individuals who have made mixtures based on bleach and acids to produce “homemade” weedkillers. However, these mixtures can cause poisoning that may lead to hospitalization.
By mixing bleach and household hydrochloric acid, a student suffered such poisoning. Fortunately, the release of gas was much less significant than it should have been, which limited the effects of the poisoning to coughing and severe headaches.
The chemical transformation that makes this mixture so dangerous is studied in the first part of the exercise. The next two parts aim to understand what reduced the gas release and thus limited the severity of the poisoning.
Part A – Study of chlorine gas release
Hydrochloric acid and bleach are two products commonly used in a household context for their complementary properties – descaling for one, antiseptic for the other. It is therefore tempting to mix them in order to combine these properties. However, this is extremely dangerous because of a very rapid release of chlorine gas ($Cl_2$), a green, dense, and very toxic gas. Moreover, the chemical transformation responsible for this gas release consumes the active ingredients of bleach (hypochlorite ions, $ClO^-$) and hydrochloric acid (oxonium ions, $H_3O^+$), neutralizing the antiseptic and descaling properties.
Bleach is a basic solution containing hypochlorite ($ClO^-$), chloride ($Cl^-$), hydroxide ($HO^-$), and sodium ($Na^+$) ions. The hypochlorite ion is the conjugate base of hypochlorous acid ($HClO$).
Data:
- The pH of a bleach solution is between 11.5 and 12.5.
- The $pK_A$ value of the acid-base pair $HClO/ClO^-$ is 7.5.
Q1- Draw the predominance diagram for the pair $HClO/ClO^-$.
Q2- Indicate which species of the pair $HClO/ClO^-$ predominates in bleach.
The student mentioned in the introduction mixed one liter of bleach with an equal volume of household hydrochloric acid ($H_3O^+ ; Cl^-$). Before mixing, the bleach has a hypochlorite ion concentration $C_0$ of $0.40\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$. After mixing, the resulting solution, denoted $S_m$, has a pH close to 0.
Q3- Justify that, in solution $S_m$, almost all the hypochlorite ions have been transformed into hypochlorous acid.
In addition to these acid-base properties, hypochlorous acid $HClO$ and chloride ion $Cl^-$ also form redox couples with dichlorine $Cl_2$:
- Hypochlorous acid is the oxidizing agent of the couple $HClO/Cl_2$.
- The chloride ion is the reducing agent of the couple $Cl_2/Cl^-$.
These redox properties are responsible for the formation of chlorine in acidic medium.
Q4- Write the redox half-equations for the couples $Cl_2/Cl^-$ and $HClO/Cl_2$ (in acidic medium).
Q5- Deduce that the overall reaction equation for chloride ions with hypochlorous acid is:
$Cl^-(aq) + HClO(aq) + H_3O^+(aq) \rightleftharpoons Cl_2(g) + 2\ H_2O(\ell)$
This redox transformation is possible only in a strongly acidic medium (pH < 2), which is the case in solution $S_m$ obtained by the student after mixing bleach and household hydrochloric acid.
It is considered that, just after mixing, the two liters of solution $S_m$ contain an amount of substance $n_{HClO} = 0.40\ \mathrm{mol}$ of hypochlorous acid and that the transformation producing chlorine begins: the solution therefore starts releasing very toxic chlorine gas.
We want to estimate the volume of chlorine theoretically produced during this mixing. For this, it is accepted that, under the conditions described:
- The chlorine-forming transformation is complete.
- Hypochlorous acid is the limiting reactant.
Q6- Show that the amount of substance of chlorine $n_{Cl_2}$ theoretically produced by the transformation is $0.40\ \mathrm{mol}$.
Q7- Using the molar volume of gaseous chlorine, deduce the value of the volume $V_{Cl_2}$ occupied by the chlorine gas theoretically produced by the transformation.
Data: molar volume of gaseous chlorine under a pressure of one atmosphere at a temperature of 20 °C: $V_m(Cl_2(g)) = 24\ \mathrm{L\cdot mol^{-1}}$.
Even outdoors, such an amount of gas could have had dramatic consequences. However, the amount of gas produced was much smaller, limiting the severity of the accident. In what follows, we seek the cause of this welcome anomaly.
Part B – State of preservation of hydrochloric acid
The first lead is the hydrochloric acid bottle used. Indeed, if its concentration is significantly lower than expected, the consumption of oxonium ions during chlorine production is likely to raise the pH rapidly enough to stop the redox reaction.
Hydrochloric acid is an aqueous solution obtained by dissolving gaseous hydrogen chloride $HCl(g)$ in water. Since hydrogen chloride is a strong acid in water, it dissociates completely to form oxonium ions $H_3O^+(aq)$ and chloride ions $Cl^-(aq)$. Document 1 gathers some information about the bottle used.
Document 1 – Information on the hydrochloric acid bottle used. The document shows a bottle label “hydrochloric acid 23 %” indicating in particular “descaling”, “stripping” and “pH regulation”. The written data are: molar mass of hydrogen chloride: $M(HCl)=36.5\ \mathrm{g\cdot mol^{-1}}$; mass fraction of hydrochloric acid in the solution: $w=\dfrac{\mathrm{mass\ of\ HCl}}{\mathrm{mass\ of\ solution}}=23\ \%$; density of the commercial solution: $\rho=1120.0\ \mathrm{g\cdot L^{-1}}$.
Q8- Show that, according to the label, the amount concentration $C_a$ in oxonium ions in the commercial solution should be about $7\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$.
To experimentally verify this concentration value, a titration of hydrochloric acid by a sodium hydroxide solution ($Na^+(aq) + HO^-(aq)$) is carried out with pH monitoring.
Q9- Write the reaction equation for the titration between the oxonium ion and the hydroxide ion.
To perform the titration, a freshly prepared sodium hydroxide solution of concentration $C_b = 2.0 \times 10^{-2}\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$ is used. Moreover, the commercial hydrochloric acid solution is not titrated directly. A solution S is prepared by diluting the commercial solution by a factor of 500, and a volume $V_S = 20.0\ \mathrm{mL}$ of solution S is titrated.
Let $C_S$ be the concentration in oxonium ions of solution S.
Q10- Calculate the volume of commercial solution to take in order to prepare 1.0 L of solution S.
Q11- Propose a protocol to prepare 1 L of solution S, specifying the glassware used (type and volume).
A volume $V_S = 20.0\ \mathrm{mL}$ of solution S is measured with a volumetric pipette and titrated with pH monitoring. Document 2 gathers the measured pH values plotted as a function of the volume $V_b$ of base added; the derivative $dpH/dV_b$ is also shown.
Q12- Verify that the concentration in oxonium ions of the hydrochloric acid commercial solution is indeed the value estimated in question Q8.
To answer this question, the candidate is invited to take initiative and present the approach followed, even if it did not lead to a result. The approach is assessed and must be properly presented.
Document 2 – Variation of pH and its derivative as a function of $V_b$ during the titration. Graph with horizontal axis $V_b$ in mL from 0 to about 24; left vertical axis: pH from 0 to 12; right vertical axis: $dpH/dV_b$ from 0 to about 5. The pH curve starts at about pH 1.9 at $V_b=0$, rises slowly (pH ≈ 2.2 at 5 mL; ≈ 2.6 at 10 mL; ≈ 3.2 at 13 mL), shows a jump around 14 mL (pH ≈ 8 at 14.2 mL; ≈ 10 at 14.8 mL), then tends toward pH 11 at 16 mL and about 11.6 at 24 mL. The derivative curve is almost zero before 11 mL, increases sharply from 12 mL, reaches a maximum around $V_b \approx 14.0\ \mathrm{mL}$ of about 4.5 on the right axis, then falls back toward zero after 16–18 mL. The equivalence volume is therefore read at the maximum of the derivative, around 14.0 mL.
Part C – Preservation of bleach
Since the hydrochloric acid had the expected concentration, another possible cause of the small amount of chlorine produced during the accident is degradation of the bleach. Indeed, the hypochlorite ion $ClO^-$ is strongly oxidizing: this gives it its antiseptic properties but also allows it to react with water. This reaction, which is very slow, leads to the gradual degradation of bleach.
The action of hypochlorite ions on water is described by the reaction equation below:
$2\ ClO^-(aq) + 2\ H_2O(\ell) \rightarrow 2\ Cl^-(aq) + O_2(g) + 2\ H_2O(\ell)$
The bleach bottle used by the student is a commercial solution at 2.6 % available chlorine, which corresponds to an expected hypochlorite ion concentration of $C_0 = 0.40\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$. The bottle bears the label “store in a cool place”.
Document 3 shows how the concentration $C$ in hypochlorite ions of three solutions identical to that of the student, stored under different temperature conditions, varies over time.
Q13- Define the half-reaction time and explain how to measure it in the special case of the “30 °C” curve in document 3.
Q14- Using the half-reaction time, characterize the influence of temperature on the kinetics of the transformation studied by exploiting document 3.
Q15- Justify the recommendation “store in a cool place”.
The bleach bottle used by the student had been opened for 18 months and had been stored at a temperature of 20 °C.
Q16- Justify that this can explain the small amount of gas produced during the accident.
Document 3 – Variation of the concentration in hypochlorite ions of bleach solutions stored at different temperatures. Graph: vertical axis $C$ in $\mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$ from 0 to 0.40; horizontal axis $t$ in days from 0 to 700. Three decreasing curves start from $C=0.40\ \mathrm{mol\cdot L^{-1}}$ at $t=0$. Curve 20 °C: slowest decrease, about $C=0.25$ at 120 days, $0.17$ at 200 days, $0.10$ at 330 days, $0.05$ at 500 days, and $0.025$ at 700 days; approximate half-reaction time around 170 days. Curve 30 °C: intermediate decrease, about $C=0.20$ at 90 days, $0.12$ at 170 days, $0.06$ at 270 days, $0.025$ at 400 days, and close to 0 at 700 days; approximate half-reaction time around 90 days. Curve 35 °C: fastest decrease, about $C=0.20$ at 65 days, $0.10$ at 130 days, $0.05$ at 250 days, $0.02$ at 340 days, and almost zero after 500–700 days; approximate half-reaction time around 65 days.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise