Baccalauréat 2024 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Asie (jour 1) — exercise 2 : Distant Observation (official exam paper)
Statement
In clear weather, it is possible to glimpse the ridge of the Arcaja (northern Corsica) from the Mercantour massif (southern France), even though they are separated by about 195 km.
This exercise studies the conditions required to distinguish the blades of a wind turbine located on the Arcaja ridge from the Mercantour massif. To do so, we first consider naked-eye observation, then observation with an afocal telescope.
Introductory figure: profile diagram showing, on the left, the Mercantour massif with an observer; on the right, the Arcaja ridge carrying a wind turbine; a horizontal arrow between the two indicates 195 km.
Data:
- Distance between the observation site and the Arcaja ridge: $D = 195\ \mathrm{km}$.
- Length of a wind turbine blade: $L = 44\ \mathrm{m}$.
Discriminability with the naked eye
First, we study the possibility of distinguishing the blades of the wind turbine with the naked eye.
The ability to distinguish details on distant objects with the naked eye is characterized by the resolving power of the eye. Denoted $\varepsilon$ and expressed in radians, this resolving power corresponds to the minimum angle that must exist between the rays coming from two objects A and B when they reach the eye of a distant observer for A and B to be distinguished. Let $\theta$ be the angle between these rays (see document 1); the rule is therefore:
- If $\theta > \varepsilon$, points A and B are perceived as distinct (the extent of object AB is perceived).
- If $\theta < \varepsilon$, points A and B are perceived as a single point.
Document 1 – Naked-eye observation of a distant object. Diagram: a vertical segment AB is located on the left, A at the bottom and B at the top. Two rays from A and B converge toward an eye located on the right. The angle between these two rays, near the eye, is denoted $\theta$.
Data:
- Resolving power of the observer’s eye: $\varepsilon = 3,0 \times 10^{-4}\ \mathrm{rad}$.
- For very small angles, expressed in radians: $\tan \theta \approx \theta$.
Q1- Show that the value of the angle $\theta$ when the observer tries to observe a blade of the wind turbine with the naked eye is $2,3 \times 10^{-4}\ \mathrm{rad}$.
Q2- State whether the observer succeeds in distinguishing the wind turbine blade with the naked eye.
Use of an afocal telescope
To better distinguish distant objects, one of the simplest methods is to use a spotting telescope, or afocal telescope. Such a telescope changes the path of the rays coming from points A and B so that they reach the observer’s eye under a new angle $\theta'$ greater than the initial angle $\theta$. The telescope’s “magnification”, denoted $G$, is the ratio between $\theta'$ and $\theta$:
$G = \dfrac{\theta'}{\theta}$
The criterion for being able to distinguish details of a distant object through the afocal telescope then becomes:
$\theta' > \varepsilon$
The observer wishes to build an afocal telescope in order to distinguish the wind turbine blades. To do this, they need to know the relationship between the telescope’s magnification and the characteristic quantities of the elements that make it up.
They choose to make the telescope using two converging lenses $L_1$ and $L_2$ fixed at the ends of tubes that can slide inside one another (see document 2). Lens $L_1$ is oriented toward the distant object to be observed and the eye is positioned after lens $L_2$.
Document 2 – Diagram of the homemade astronomical telescope (the graduations are in centimeters). Horizontal diagram: on the left, the distant object; then a vertical lens $L_1$ fixed at the end of tube 1. An upper scale graduated from 0 to 25 cm extends from $L_1$ to the right. A tube 2 slides inside tube 1 to the right; a second upper scale, attached to tube 2, is graduated from 20 to 0 from left to right. At the right end is lens $L_2$ and the observer’s eye is placed to the right of $L_2$.
In the following, this device is studied in order to identify how the lenses must be positioned to assemble an afocal telescope, and then to characterize the magnification of the telescope obtained.
To carry out this study, we rely on the diagram in the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET. It is a principle diagram; it is not to scale. [The appendix on page 13/13 is not provided in the transmitted pages.]
We denote:
- $F_1$, $F'_1$, $F_2$ and $F'_2$ respectively the object and image focal points of lenses $L_1$ and $L_2$.
- $f'_1$ and $f'_2$ the focal lengths of these lenses.
Q3- On the diagram in the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET, assign the terms objective and eyepiece to the lenses.
The principle of an afocal telescope is to form the image at infinity of an object located at infinity.
Q4- By explaining the reasoning used, indicate how the object focal point of the eyepiece must be positioned relative to the image focal point of the objective in order to form an afocal telescope.
Q5- Place the focal points $F_2$ and $F'_2$ of lens $L_2$ on the diagram in the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET.
Q6- Deduce the expression for the distance $d = O_1O_2$ that must separate lenses $L_1$ and $L_2$, as a function of $f'_1$ and $f'_2$, for the telescope to be afocal.
To determine the expression for the magnification, the path of rays coming from a distant point B off the optical axis must be studied.
Q7- On the diagram in the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET, draw the path of the two light rays coming from the distant point B through the telescope, showing the intermediate image $A_1B_1$ that forms in the telescope.
Q8- On the diagram in the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET, place the angles $\theta$ and $\theta'$.
Q9- Using the diagram obtained, show that the magnification $G$ can be expressed in terms of the focal lengths of the lenses by the relation:
$G = \dfrac{f'_1}{f'_2}$
To assemble the telescope, the observer has a set of lenses with focal lengths listed below.
Data:
- Focal lengths of the available lenses: $5,0\ \mathrm{cm}$; $10,0\ \mathrm{cm}$; $12,5\ \mathrm{cm}$; $20,0\ \mathrm{cm}$; $30,0\ \mathrm{cm}$.
- Distance between the observation site and the Arcaja ridge: $D = 195\ \mathrm{km}$.
- Length of a wind turbine blade: $L = 44\ \mathrm{m}$.
- Resolving power of the observer’s eye: $\varepsilon = 3,0 \times 10^{-4}\ \mathrm{rad}$.
Important - observation criterion: the criterion adopted is that the observer will be able to distinguish the blades “comfortably” if the angle $\theta'$ is at least four times greater than the resolving power of the naked eye.
Q10- Propose a choice of lenses for the objective and the eyepiece that would allow the observer to distinguish the wind turbine blades comfortably.
To answer this question, the candidate is invited to take initiative and present the method followed even if it did not lead to a result. The approach is assessed and must be presented correctly.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise