Baccalauréat 2024 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Métropole, La Réunion, Mayotte (jour 1) — exercise 1 : Towards Thymol Blue (official exam paper)
Statement
Thymol blue is an acid-base color indicator increasingly used in laboratories. According to the recommendations of the INRS (French National Research and Safety Institute), it is indeed replacing phenolphthalein, which was commonly used before and is now classified as CMR (Carcinogenic, Mutagenic, Reprotoxic). As shown in Figure 1, thymol blue can be synthesized from thymol, itself extracted from the thyme plant or synthesized from m-cresol.
Figure 1. Possible methods of obtaining thymol blue. The figure shows a chain: bunch of thyme → extraction of the oil → thyme essential oil → extraction of thymol → thymol → synthesis → thymol blue. Another route shows m-cresol → synthesis → thymol. The topological formulas shown are those of m-cresol, thymol and thymol blue.
The aim of this exercise is to study two methods of obtaining thymol and then to focus on thymol blue as an alternative to phenolphthalein as a color indicator.
1. Successive extractions
Thyme is a small plant cultivated since antiquity in the Mediterranean region. Appreciated in cooking for its aromas, the plant is also used for its therapeutic properties due to thymol, the main constituent of the species of thyme studied in this exercise.
Data:
- thymol, at room temperature, appears as colorless crystals with a characteristic odor;
- the solubility of thymol is low in water and high in organic solvents;
- processing a 100 g sample of French thyme makes it possible to obtain at most 2 g of thyme essential oil;
- the electronic configuration of oxygen in its ground state is: $(1s)^2(2s)^2(2p)^4$;
- hexane is an organic solvent with density $d = 0.66$ and is immiscible with water;
- the thymol / thymolate ion pair is denoted: $R–OH / R–O^-$.
Q1. Write the semi-developed formula of thymol then circle and name its functional group.
Q2. Draw the Lewis structure of the thymolate ion, written $R–O^-$.
From thyme to thyme essential oil
Hydrodistillation is one of the essential oil extraction techniques recommended by European legislation.
Following the hydrodistillation of a thyme sample, thin-layer chromatography is carried out on the essential oil obtained, with the samples dissolved in a suitable solvent. The chromatogram is shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2. Chromatogram obtained. The plate shows three deposits aligned on the baseline: HEe, HEc and Tc. The solvent front is a horizontal line near the top of the plate. The HEe deposit (essential oil obtained experimentally) gives several spots at different heights, including a low spot, an intermediate spot and a higher spot; the HEc deposit (commercial thyme essential oil) also gives several spots, some at the same heights as those of the HEe deposit; the Tc deposit (commercial thymol) gives a single spot at a height corresponding to a spot observed for HEe. Legend: HEe deposit: essential oil obtained experimentally; HEc deposit: commercial thyme essential oil; Tc deposit: commercial thymol.
Q3. Justify that the essential oil obtained experimentally is a mixture that contains thymol.
From essential oil to thymol
A scientific article proposes the following protocol for extracting thymol from the essential oil:
- add 1.0 mL of thyme essential oil to 5 mL of aqueous sodium hydroxide solution;
- after heating in a microwave oven, remove the oil phase then acidify the aqueous phase using hydrochloric acid;
- add hexane, shake, allow to settle and recover the phase containing thymol.
After evaporation of the solvent, crystals are obtained whose mass corresponds to 31 % of the mass of thymol initially present in the essential oil.
From Journal of Medicinal Plants and By-products, 2021
Data:
- the average mass percentage of thymol in thyme essential oil is 53 %.
Q4. Write the reaction equation modeling the action of hydrochloric acid on the thymolate ion $R–O^-$.
Q5. Deduce the nature and position of the phase in which thymol is found after decantation.
Q6. Show that the mass of thyme plant needed to obtain 1 g of thymol is close to 300 g.
2. Synthesis of thymol
The thymol used in pharmaceutical products is mainly obtained by synthesis. As indicated in Figure 3, thymol can be industrially synthesized from m-cresol and propene in excess, in the presence of aluminum oxide, which acts here as a catalyst. This transformation generates several by-products and makes selective obtaining of thymol complex.
Figure 3. Example of a thymol synthesis process. The reaction scheme shows: m-cresol + propene, in the presence of aluminum oxide $Al_2O_3$, giving thymol.
Data:
- density of water: $1.00×10^3$ g·L$^{-1}$;
- table gathering physical and chemical properties of some molecules:
Table. Columns: Molecule; m-cresol; propene; thymol; some by-products P1, P2, P3, P4. Row “Topological formula”: the corresponding topological formulas are shown; m-cresol is a methylphenol; propene is $CH_3–CH=CH_2$; thymol is a methyl-isopropyl-phenol; P1 to P4 are phenolic aromatic products substituted by methyl and isopropyl groups at different positions. Row “Boiling point (°C)”: m-cresol 203; propene −47.7; thymol 233; P1, P2, P3 and P4: value not given (dash). Row “Molar mass (g·mol$^{-1}$)”: m-cresol 108.1; propene 42.1; thymol 150.2; P1, P2, P3 and P4: value not given (dash). Row “Density”: m-cresol 1.03; propene: dash; thymol: dash; P1, P2, P3 and P4: dash.
Q7. Determine whether the by-products P2 and P4 of the reaction are isomers of thymol.
Many catalysts have recently been developed with the aim, among other things, of reducing the synthesis temperature and obtaining maximum selectivity in thymol.
Q8. Give the definition of a catalyst and indicate how its use can make it possible to “reduce the synthesis temperature”.
We consider that the transformation between m-cresol and propene is not complete and that the final state of the transformation is a chemical equilibrium state.
Q9. Explain the advantage of introducing propene in excess in this industrial synthesis.
An industrial fractional distillation makes it possible to purify thymol and recover the unreacted m-cresol for recycling.
Q10. Justify that thymol and m-cresol can a priori be separated during fractional distillation. Indicate which species would be recovered first.
Q11. Considering m-cresol as the limiting reactant in the transformation, whose yield is 73 %, verify that the volume of m-cresol needed to synthesize 1.0 g of thymol by the process in Figure 3 is less than 1 mL.
3. Thymol blue
Phenolphthalein is an acid-base color indicator suitable for titrations of weak acid. The aim of this part is to show that the same is true for thymol blue.
Data:
- phenolphthalein: acid-base color indicator changing from colorless to pink in the experimental transition pH range $[8.2 – 9.9]$;
- thymol blue: acid-base color indicator having three forms participating in two acid-base pairs with simplified notation $BTH_2(aq) / BTH^-(aq)$ and $BTH^-(aq) / BT^{2-}(aq)$;
- to discuss whether a measurement result agrees with a reference value, one may use the quotient $|x-x_{ref}|/u(x)$ with $x$ the measured value, $x_{ref}$ the reference value and $u(x)$ the standard uncertainty associated with the measured value $x$.
Figure 4. Simulation of the titration of 10.0 mL of a solution of a weak acid (ethanoic acid) with concentration 0.100 mol·L$^{-1}$ by a solution of strong base (sodium hydroxide) with concentration 0.100 mol·L$^{-1}$. Graph pH as a function of volume $V$ in mL. The horizontal axis runs from 0 to 20 mL; the vertical pH axis runs from 0 to 14. The curve starts around pH 3 for $V=0$, increases slowly to about pH 6 at $V=9.5$ mL, shows a pH jump centered around $V=10$ mL, rising approximately from pH 6 to pH 11.5, then reaches a plateau near pH 12.5 at 20 mL.
Figure 5. Distribution diagram of thymol blue species (from BUP, May 2019). Graph of proportions (%) as a function of pH from 0 to 12. Three curves: proportion of $BTH_2$ (triangles), proportion of $BTH^-$ (dots), proportion of $BT^{2-}$ (crosses). $BTH_2$ is predominant at very low pH, is about 50 % at pH 1.4 and becomes almost zero at pH 3. $BTH^-$ increases to about 100 % between pH 3 and 6.5, then decreases; it is about 50 % at pH 8.9 and becomes almost zero at pH 10.5. $BT^{2-}$ is almost zero up to pH 7, then increases, is about 50 % at pH 8.9 and becomes close to 100 % at pH 10.5.
Figure 6. UV-visible absorption spectrum of the three acid-base forms of thymol blue (from BUP, May 2019). Graph of absorbance $A$ as a function of wavelength $\lambda$ from 350 to 800 nm. The curves associated with $BTH_2$, $BTH^-$ and $BT^{2-}$ are indicated. $BTH^-$ shows significant absorption in the violet-blue region with a maximum around 440 nm; $BT^{2-}$ shows a maximum absorbance around 595-600 nm; the $BTH_2$ form shows absorption in the region around 400 nm and a band in the region around 540-550 nm. The maximum absorbance read is of the order of 0.9 to 1.0 for $BT^{2-}$, and of the order of 0.3 to 0.4 for $BTH^-$.
Figure 7. Color wheel. The wheel indicates approximate colors and wavelengths: violet 400 nm, blue 450 nm, green 500 nm, yellow 570 nm, orange 590 nm, red 630 to 700 nm.
Q12. Among the species participating in the acid-base pairs of thymol blue, identify the amphoteric form.
Q13. Express the acidity constant $K_A$ of an acid-base pair written $HA / A^-$ in terms of the concentrations of the species associated with the equilibrium.
Q14. Using all the information provided, determine the value of the $pK_A$ of the $BTH^-(aq) / BT^{2-}(aq)$ pair of thymol blue. Justify that it can replace phenolphthalein in our laboratories, specifying the color change observed during the titration of a weak acid by a strong base.
The candidate is invited to take initiatives and present their approach even if it was unsuccessful. The approach followed is assessed and therefore needs to be correctly presented.
Q15. The tabulated value of the $pK_A$ at 25 °C of the acid-base pair $BTH^-(aq) / BT^{2-}(aq)$ is 8.9. Indicate whether the experimental value obtained is in agreement with it. The standard uncertainty associated with the $pK_A$ determined by this method is estimated at $u(pK_A) = 0.2$.
⏳ Solution not generated yet
Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.
📝 See the solutionHave a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.
🧮 Solve my exercise