Solved exercises🧮 Solve my exercise

Baccalauréat 2024 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Métropole (jour 1) remplacement — exercise 2 : The Discovery of Neptune (official exam paper)

PhysicsLevel : High schoolThe Discovery of Neptune🌐 Lire en français
Statement
Following the discovery of the planet Uranus in 1781 and the study of its trajectory, some astronomers supposed the existence of another planet that would influence its motion. In 1846, the Frenchman Urbain Le Verrier succeeded in proposing, by calculation, the characteristics of this new planet. Thanks to Le Verrier’s indications and with the help of the astronomical telescope of the Berlin Observatory, the astronomer Johann Galle spotted, during his very first nights of observation, the new celestial body that has since been called Neptune. The aim of this exercise is to analyze some of Le Verrier’s predictions and then to study the observation of Neptune with the astronomical telescope of the Berlin Observatory. 1. The characteristics of Neptune according to Le Verrier’s predictions Data: - conversion of a distance expressed in meters (m) into a distance expressed in astronomical units (AU): $1\ \mathrm{UA} = 1.50\times 10^{11}\ \mathrm{m}$; - currently accepted reference values for some planetary parameters: - semi-major axis of the orbit of the planet Uranus: $a_{\mathrm{Réf\ U}} = 19.2\ \mathrm{UA}$; - revolution period of the planet Uranus around the Sun: $T_{\mathrm{Réf\ U}} = 84.1\ \mathrm{ans}$; - revolution period of the planet Neptune around the Sun: $T_{\mathrm{Réf\ N}} = 165\ \mathrm{ans}$; - the planet Neptune is farther from the Sun than the planet Uranus; - to discuss whether a measured result agrees with a reference value, one may use the quotient $\dfrac{|x-x_{\mathrm{ref}}|}{u(x)}$ with $x$ the measured value, $x_{\mathrm{ref}}$ the reference value, and $u(x)$ the standard uncertainty associated with the measured value $x$. In Figure 1 below, the elliptical orbit of a planet around the Sun and the semi-major axis $a$ of this orbit are shown. Figure 1. Elliptical orbit, with semi-major axis $a$, of a planet around the Sun: diagram of a horizontal ellipse. The center $O$ of the ellipse is marked in the middle; the Sun is placed on the major axis to the right of $O$, at one focus of the ellipse; a planet is located on the upper right part of the ellipse. The segment labeled $a$ starts from the center $O$ toward the left edge of the ellipse and corresponds to the semi-major axis. Q1. Name the special position occupied by the Sun for the ellipse represented in Figure 1. State the name of the astronomer known for having established this result. It can be shown that for all objects in elliptical orbit around the Sun, the ratio $\dfrac{T^2}{a^3}$ between the square of the revolution period $T$ and the cube of the semi-major axis $a$ of the orbit is the same. Q2. Justify that the revolution period of Neptune is greater than that of Uranus. In his memoir presented in 1846, Le Verrier states that, according to his calculations, Neptune has an elliptical orbit with semi-major axis $a_{\mathrm{Verrier\ N}} = 36.2\ \mathrm{UA}$. Q3. Determine, using $a_{\mathrm{Réf\ U}}$, $T_{\mathrm{Réf\ U}}$ and $a_{\mathrm{Verrier\ N}}$, the value in years of the revolution period $T_{\mathrm{Verrier\ N}}$ of the planet Neptune for the orbit predicted by Le Verrier. Thanks to Le Verrier’s memoir, it is possible to estimate the standard uncertainty $u(T_{\mathrm{Verrier\ N}})$ associated with the value $T_{\mathrm{Verrier\ N}}$ obtained in Q3: $u(T_{\mathrm{Verrier\ N}}) = 13\ \mathrm{ans}$. Q4. Discuss whether the result for $T_{\mathrm{Verrier\ N}}$ agrees with the current reference value $T_{\mathrm{Réf\ N}}$. Le Verrier carried out his calculations by studying the perturbations exerted by Uranus on Neptune. Uranus’s orbit had not yet been described precisely at the beginning of the 19th century. Le Verrier was therefore forced to make several approximations, which explains the difference obtained for the calculated trajectory of Neptune, as shown in Figure 2. Figure 2. Orbits of Uranus and Neptune (the diagram is not to scale), after The Discovery of Neptune by Le Verrier (1846), James Lequeux: polar diagram centered on the Sun with angular axes 0° to the left, 90° at the top, 180° at the bottom, and 270° to the right. Three circular or nearly circular orbits are shown: Uranus’s orbit is the innermost, then Neptune’s actual orbit, then Le Verrier’s predicted orbit, which is farther out. Points indicate positions at different dates from 1800 to 1846. On Uranus’s orbit, positions are marked 1800, 1810, 1820, 1830, 1840, 1846. On the Neptune orbits, similar positions are indicated; the actual and predicted 1846 positions are close in the upper left part of the diagram, but the predicted orbit has a larger radius than the actual orbit. Q5. Using Figure 2, compare qualitatively the value of the semi-major axis of the orbit predicted by Le Verrier with the value of the semi-major axis of Neptune’s actual orbit. Show that the answer is consistent with the results of question Q3. 2. Observation of Neptune Data: - distance between Neptune and Earth in August 1846: $d_{T-N} = 4.4\times 10^9\ \mathrm{km}$; - diameter of Neptune: $D = 4.95\times 10^4\ \mathrm{km}$; - angular resolution of the eye: two different points of a celestial body can be distinguished if the angle under which these two points are seen from Earth is greater than or equal to approximately $3\times 10^{-4}\ \mathrm{rad}$; - small-angle approximation ($\theta \ll 1\ \mathrm{rad}$): $\tan \theta = \theta$. Galle’s observation of Neptune with the astronomical telescope of the Berlin Observatory was carried out in August 1846. Let $\theta$ be the angle under which Neptune could be seen with the naked eye from Earth at the end of summer 1846. Q6. Using the data, show that the value of the angle $\theta$ is close to $1.1\times 10^{-5}\ \mathrm{rad}$. The telescope under study is modeled by a system of two converging thin lenses, denoted $L_1$ and $L_2$, as shown in Figure 3 of the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET. This telescope consists of an objective lens ($L_1$) and an eyepiece lens ($L_2$), whose optical centers are denoted respectively by $O_1$ and $O_2$ and whose image foci are represented by $F’_1$ and $F’_2$. The image focus $F’_1$ of the objective is also coincident with the object focus $F_2$ of the eyepiece. In Figure 3 of the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET, the planet Neptune is modeled by an object AB located at infinity. Point A is on the optical axis. The rays arriving from A are parallel to the optical axis. Point B is off the optical axis. The rays coming from B are parallel to each other and reach lens $L_1$ with an inclination $\theta$ relative to the optical axis. Q7. Explain why Figure 3 of the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET represents an afocal astronomical telescope. Q8. On Figure 3 of the APPENDIX TO BE SUBMITTED WITH THE ANSWER SHEET, complete the path of the three light rays of the incident beam coming from B already drawn and passing through the whole telescope. Note about the appendix: in the provided pages, Figure 3 of the appendix is not visible; page 12 is a blank page bearing the statement “Blank page intentionally left blank. Do not write anything on it.” Let $\theta’$ be the angle under which the image formed by the astronomical telescope is seen and $G = \dfrac{\theta’}{\theta}$ its magnification. Two characteristics of the astronomical telescope present at the Berlin Observatory in August 1846 are given: - focal length of the objective: $f’_1 = 4.27\ \mathrm{m}$; - focal length of the eyepiece: $f’_2 = 28\ \mathrm{mm}$. Effects related to diffraction will be neglected when observing Neptune with this astronomical telescope. Le Verrier wrote: “not only will the new planet be visible in good telescopes, but its disk will also be distinguishable; its appearance will not be reduced to that of a [point-like] star.” Q9. After establishing the expression for the magnification $G$ in terms of the focal lengths $f’_1$ and $f’_2$, calculate the value of the angle $\theta’$ under which Galle could observe Neptune with the astronomical telescope of the Berlin Observatory. Comment on Le Verrier’s statement. The candidate is invited to take initiative and present the approach followed, even if it did not lead to a result. The approach is assessed and must be presented correctly.
⏳ Solution not generated yet

Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.

📝 See the solution

Have a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.

🧮 Solve my exercise