Solved exercises🧮 Solve my exercise

Baccalauréat 2024 — Physics-Chemistry specialty, Asie (jour 2) — exercise 1 : Weaving of a boat sail (official exam paper)

PhysicsLevel : High schoolWeaving of a boat sail🌐 Lire en français
Statement
Until recently, the sails of sailboats were made using a weaving of nylon threads. However, over the past decade, newer, more efficient composite materials (kevlar, carbon) have been used to make the threads. In addition, they can be woven more or less tightly depending on the stresses to which the different parts of the sail are subjected. The aim of this exercise is to study the possibility of distinguishing these weaves. Direct observation, with the naked eye and with the help of a magnifying glass, is studied in the first part. A second part is devoted to the use of the interference phenomenon. The object of study is a sail made of carbon threads. The weave is represented in document 1. It is characterized by two main parameters: • The diameter of the threads, denoted $a$. • The spacing between the threads, denoted $b$. It also corresponds to the spacing between the gaps and is assumed to be identical in the two directions of the weave. Document 1 – Characteristics of the weave Weave of carbon threads. Thread diameter: $a = 10\ \mu\text{m}$. Spacing between threads: $b$. The spacing $b$ depends on the area of the sail. It lies between 12 and 25 $\mu\text{m}$. The diagram shows a grid of gray horizontal and vertical threads: the diameter of one thread is denoted $a$; the empty space between two neighboring threads, horizontally as well as vertically, is denoted $b$. Part 1 – Direct observation First, we seek to observe the weave with the naked eye. We adopt as an observation criterion the ability to distinguish the thickness of the threads of diameter $a$. The eye’s ability to distinguish an object depends on the “angular field” it occupies in the field of view. The angular field, denoted $\theta$ below, is defined as the angle between the rays coming from the edges of the observed object when they reach the center of the pupil (see document 2, page 3). The resolving power of the eye, denoted $\varepsilon$, corresponds to the minimum angular field that an object must occupy in order to be distinguished. In other words: • If $\theta > \varepsilon$: the object can be distinguished; its ends are perceived as distinct points. • If $\theta < \varepsilon$: the object cannot be distinguished; it is perceived as a single point. To increase the chances of distinguishing an object, it must be observed under the largest possible angular field. For this, one can move closer to the object. However, the eye has a limit in its ability to see nearby objects clearly. Let $d$ be the distance between the observed object and the eye (see document 2, page 3); it is estimated that most people cannot see clearly an object located at a distance smaller than $d_m = 0{,}25\ \text{m}$. Document 2 – Observation of an object: angular field, observation distance Reference values: resolving power $\varepsilon = 3{,}0 \times 10^{-4}\ \text{rad}$; minimum observation distance $d_m = 0{,}25\ \text{m}$. The diagram shows a vertical object $AB$ seen by the eye at a distance $d$; the angle between the ray coming from $A$ and the ray coming from $B$ is $\theta$. In this whole part, the angles studied are always very small. We may therefore use the small-angle approximation: $\tan\theta \approx \theta$ (with $\theta$ in radian). Consider an observer looking at the sail fabric from the distance $d_m$. The observer wants to distinguish the thickness of the threads, characterized by their diameter $a = 10\ \mu\text{m}$. Let $\theta_a$ be the angular field corresponding to the thickness of a thread. Q1- Express the angular field $\theta_a$ in terms of $a$ and $d_m$. Q2- Evaluate $\theta_a$. Q3- Justify that the observer cannot distinguish the thickness of the threads with the naked eye. To overcome this difficulty, the observer decides to use a magnifying glass. A magnifying glass is an optical system consisting of a single converging lens. It is used to “enlarge” small objects, meaning that the magnifying glass can produce images occupying a larger angular field than the object does. Document 3 – Formation of an image at infinity through a magnifying glass The diagram shows a converging lens with optical center $O$, object focal point $F$ placed on the left, and image focal point $F'$ placed on the right. The object $AB$ is placed near the object focal point with $A=F$, $AB$ vertical. A ray from $B$ passing through point $I$ of the lens emerges in the direction of the image focal point; its extension to the left forms the virtual image $A'B'$ at infinity. The angle between the emerging ray and the optical axis is denoted $\theta'$. Point $I$ is a construction point shown to help analyze the figure. To use a magnifying glass, the object $AB$ is placed near the object focal point $F$ of the lens. The image $A'B'$ is then formed at infinity. Since points $A'$ and $B'$ are at infinity, the angular field $\theta'$ associated with the image $A'B'$ is the same whatever the position of the observer’s eye. Thus, $\theta'$ can be characterized by studying the ray configuration at the image focal point, as shown in the figure in document 3, page 3. The observer wishes to observe the weave with the magnifying glass. They have three magnifying glasses with focal lengths respectively: 12,5 cm ; 5,0 cm ; 2,5 cm. Q4- Using document 3, page 3, show that the angular field $\theta_a'$ under which the observer sees a thread of diameter $a$ through the magnifying glass is related to the focal length $f'$ of the lens by the relation: $\theta_a' = \dfrac{a}{f'}$. Q5- Deduce that the observer can distinguish the thickness of the threads when: $f' < \dfrac{a}{\varepsilon}$. Q6- Indicate, with justification, which magnifying glass or glasses make it possible to distinguish the thickness of the threads. Part 2 – Interference analysis Observation with a magnifying glass may make it possible to distinguish the threads. However, it does not allow a precise characterization of the weave, that is, an evaluation of the spacing $b$ between the threads. To characterize this spacing more finely, another method is considered: optical interference with a laser. The principle is as follows: the part of the sail to be studied is stretched and illuminated by a laser at normal incidence. On a screen parallel to the sail placed at a distance $D$ behind it, an interference pattern is obtained. Document 4 shows the setup used with an overview of the pattern obtained. Document 4 – Setup used for interference analysis The diagram shows a laser illuminating a portion of sail; a vertical screen is placed behind the sail at the distance $D = 0{,}60\ \text{m}$. A red luminous pattern appears on the screen, made up of points and interference lines. Study of Young’s slits To interpret the pattern obtained, one can rely on the simpler case of interference by two slits (Young’s slits). The setup of the Young’s slit experiment is very similar to that described in document 4, page 4. The only difference is that the sail is replaced by a screen pierced by two slits. As for the sail weave, $b$ denotes the distance between the two slits ($b = F_1F_2$ on the figure in document 5). The interference phenomenon is directly related to the optical path difference $\delta$ between the rays coming from $F_1$ and $F_2$ when they meet at a point $M$ on the screen. Document 5 gathers this information and shows the interference pattern obtained. Document 5 – Young’s slit setup The diagram shows a laser light source illuminating two slits $F_1$ and $F_2$ separated by a distance $b$. The screen is at the distance $D = 0{,}60\ \text{m}$. Point $O$ is on the screen opposite the midpoint of the slits and the vertical axis of the screen is denoted $x$; a point $M$ is located at abscissa $x$ above $O$. On the right, the appearance of the screen is a regular alternation of bright and dark horizontal fringes; point A is on a dark fringe and point B on a bright fringe. The light source is a laser of wavelength $\lambda$. In an interference situation, two extreme cases are distinguished: constructive interference and destructive interference. Q7- Indicate, with justification, the nature of the interference (constructive or destructive) at points A and B marked on the figure in document 5. To exploit the interference pattern, it must be characterized using the concept of fringe spacing, whose value is related to the spacing $b$. Thus, a measurement of $b$ can be deduced from the measurement of the fringe spacing denoted $i$. To carry out this approach, it is necessary to know the expression of the optical path difference. In the situation of the described experiment, it can be shown that the optical path difference $\delta(M)$ at point M on the screen is given by: $\delta(M) = \dfrac{b}{D}x$. In this expression, $x$ is the abscissa of point M on the screen, with the origin at point O. Q8- Recall the definition of the fringe spacing $i$ and illustrate it with a diagram. Q9- Recall the condition on the optical path difference for constructive interference to be observed. Q10- Show that the relation linking the fringe spacing $i$ and the spacing $b$ is: $i = \dfrac{D}{b}\lambda$. Back to the sail Document 6 reproduces, at full size, the interference pattern obtained with a portion of the sail. This pattern is no longer made up of fringes but of points regularly spaced in two main directions. Document 6 – Interference pattern obtained with a portion of sail The full-size figure shows, on a black background, white luminous spots arranged in a regular horizontal and vertical grid. A horizontal axis $x$ crosses the central row. On this central row, five main spots are seen, centered approximately at the graduations 0,8 cm ; 2,1 cm ; 3,5 cm ; 4,8 cm ; 6,2 cm of the ruler printed below the figure, corresponding to an approximate spacing of 1,35 cm between neighboring centers. The graduated ruler is marked in millimeters and a reference segment indicates 1 cm. Light source used: laser diode of wavelength $\lambda = 650\ \text{nm}$. In the case of a regular weave like that of the sail, it can be shown that the relation between the fringe spacing $i$ and the spacing between threads $b$ keeps the same expression, with fringe spacing now defined as the interval between the centers of two neighboring points. Data: • $D = 0{,}60\ \text{m}$ ; $u(D) = 0{,}01\ \text{m}$. • $\lambda = 650\ \text{nm}$ ; $u(\lambda) = 10\ \text{nm}$. • Relation between standard uncertainties: $\dfrac{u(b)}{b}=\sqrt{\left(\dfrac{u(D)}{D}\right)^2+\left(\dfrac{u(i)}{i}\right)^2+\left(\dfrac{u(\lambda)}{\lambda}\right)^2}$. Q11- Determine the value of the fringe spacing $i$ of the interference pattern in document 6, page 6 with the greatest possible accuracy. Explain the method used (it is possible to use a personal graduated ruler or the ruler inserted in the figure). Q12- Estimate the standard uncertainty on this measurement of the fringe spacing. Give the reasoning in detail. Q13- Deduce an estimate of the value of the spacing $b$ with its uncertainty. For the sail studied, the spacing $b$ varies from one area of the sail to another depending on the stresses acting on the area: • In areas subjected to low stresses, $b = 25\ \mu\text{m}$. • When the stresses are significant, the weave is tighter ($b$ decreases) down to the limiting value $b = 12\ \mu\text{m}$ for the highest stresses. Q14- Discuss the compatibility of the measurement obtained in question Q13 with the weave of an area subjected to low stresses. A second interference pattern is produced with another portion of the sail. The resulting figure is shown in document 7. Q15- Justify that this portion of sail is intended to withstand greater stresses than the one studied previously. In this question, the candidate is invited to take initiative and present the method followed, even if it did not lead to a result. The method is assessed and must be clearly presented. Document 7 – Interference pattern obtained with another portion of sail The full-size figure shows, on a black background, white luminous spots that are more widely spaced than in document 6. A horizontal axis $x$ crosses three main spots of the central row, centered approximately at the graduations 0,8 cm ; 3,5 cm ; 6,2 cm of the ruler printed below the figure, corresponding to an approximate spacing of 2,7 cm between neighboring centers. The graduated ruler is marked in millimeters and a reference segment indicates 1 cm.
⏳ Solution not generated yet

Open this statement in Expert Maths AI: the step-by-step solution is computed on demand, checked by a second resolution, then published here for everyone.

📝 See the solution

Have a similar exercise? Get it solved step by step, for free.

🧮 Solve my exercise